Originally Posted by endgame
From reading multiple previous posts and my own testing I'm pretty sure your wrong. I think aotb works better with a scorpid because the scorpid poisons scale with ap. Once stacked they don't miss can't be parried,dodged or mitigated by armor. The poison also ticks twice as hard as any physical *crit* a cat or dev. attack could put out. You need to be fully raid buffed to get the full effect. On a target dummy my pet poison ticks for 1200 unbufffed the tick gains 100dmg for every 200 ap gain(You can test this out yourself on a dummy). My pet gains nearly 3k ap raid buffed and aotb up. So if my math is correct raid buffed I plan on getting 3700k scorpid ticks and 5200 with tbw + trinkets . Im testing it this week in naxx. In heroics my math so far has been right on the money. Scorpid > all . Untill the nerf that is =D
Same thing happened in BC the first few months with scorpids.
|
If Scorpid Poison scales with Pet AP, like Claw and Rake, but unlike similar spells like Poison Spit and Lighting Breath, then we have the source as to why it is so OP. Obviously that is a mistake since every other spellbased attack from pets scale with pet spellpower which can only scale with our AP (and debuffs on targets, and interestingly not totems or priest Spirit buff). The nerf to Thunderstomp was exactly such a move, change it from AP based to spellpower.
But it should be simple to do... Go to a dummy and let it apply a full stack, don't do anything yourself. Take note of the tickranges. Then give the pet an AP buff, Battle Shout or BoM would obviously be best, but even a scroll or pet food should be enough to have a variance if it scales directly with pet AP.
The reason Beast itself isn't good for this is that we really don't know what AP our pets scale from anymore. It used ot be RAP and RAP alone. But the 21% scaling on Beast fits a MAP scaling, but then AoftD should affect pet AP, but it still does. So we are quite simply not so certain what is going on anymore.