Elitist Jerks
Register
Blogs
Forums


Go Back   Elitist Jerks » Class Mechanics » Mages

Closed Thread
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
Old 02/06/10, 10:38 PM   #3466
Aestis
Von Kaiser
 
Aestis's Avatar
 
Troll Mage
 
Darkspear
Originally Posted by smoke_ View Post
/stopcasting
/cast [nochanneling] Arcane Blast.
I don't understand that macro either. From what I've read here t10 procs as soon as the MB channel ends, regardless of whether it's clipped. A [channeling:Arcane Missiles] macro would be awesome, but I've had no luck as well.

United States Offline
Old 02/07/10, 12:38 AM   #3467
 ash2ash
Operation Asian
 
ash2ash's Avatar
 
Undead Mage
 
Mal'Ganis
Originally Posted by smoke_ View Post
i just want the macro to clip Arcane Missiles but not Arcane bLast, hopefully that makes much more sense.
This is the default behavior of casting arcane blast without a macro, but I'm guessing that's not exactly what you're going for. If what you want is for the T10 bonus to apply to your Arcane blast even if you clip the missile with it, that just doesn't seem possible with macros - That would require a wait function between when you clipped the missile and when you start casting the arcane blast; the parameter would have to be equal to the client server communication time, otherwise you'd either create dead cast time or cast arcane blast without the T10 buff.

I point my camera at stuff and I press buttons:

picasaweb.google.com/pariah99

United States Offline
Old 02/07/10, 1:29 AM   #3468
Arlie
Glass Joe
 
Troll Mage
 
Mal'Ganis
The 2p T10 buff will be applied as soon as you press your AM hotkey after MB procs, even if you move, or interrupt it right away, and never get an actual single missile off. You "consume" the MB simply by pressing your AM hotkey. It doesn't matter if you clip a missile or not, or clip all of them, you'll still get the "Pushing the Limit" haste buff.

Offline
Old 02/07/10, 1:44 AM   #3469
Kevinally
Bald Bull
 
Kevinally's Avatar
 
Troll Mage
 
Trollbane
nochanneling macros are a DPS loss. This has already been discussed and proven. To add something that I guess no one realizes yet to the thread, Pushing The Limit is applied as soon as you finish the AM, regardless of if it ends on its own, or you end it. It is applied to your next spell cast without any fancy macroing, or timing your casts.

To prove this, using Quartz, I started chain casting on festergut, a very stand-and-burn fight. After MB proc'd, I casted AM, and cut it off after one missile with a cast of AB (no macro, just started casting it). My standard cast time without procs as shown on Quartz is 1.8 seconds. With the Pushing the Limits buff, that drops to 1.6 seconds, also according to Quartz. The AB I used to cut off AM was cast in 1.6 seconds.

You guys are making it way more complicated than it needs to be. You don't need any fancy macros, and at current haste levels (I assume I'm on the low side compared to most mages in ICC, from what I've read) you don't even have to change your priority system. you can still fit in 4 AB's during the haste buff, provided your latency is low enough. At 1064 haste and ~100ms latency, I squeeze it in with about a half second left on the buff. Haste isn't recalculated mid-cast, so it doesn't matter if the buff ends mid-cast. Infact, it's ideal to have it end just after you start casting the spell, if you will not be able to cast another spell with said buff.

Last edited by Kevinally : 02/07/10 at 2:40 AM.

United States Offline
Old 02/07/10, 3:38 AM   #3470
Korey
Von Kaiser
 
Human Mage
 
Lightbringer
Originally Posted by Arlie View Post
The 2p T10 buff will be applied as soon as you press your AM hotkey after MB procs, even if you move, or interrupt it right away, and never get an actual single missile off. You "consume" the MB simply by pressing your AM hotkey. It doesn't matter if you clip a missile or not, or clip all of them, you'll still get the "Pushing the Limit" haste buff.
No, the buff applies after the MB ends.

Originally Posted by Kevinally View Post
nochanneling macros are a DPS loss. This has already been discussed and proven. To add something that I guess no one realizes yet to the thread, Pushing The Limit is applied as soon as you finish the AM, regardless of if it ends on its own, or you end it. It is applied to your next spell cast without any fancy macroing, or timing your casts.

To prove this, using Quartz, I started chain casting on festergut, a very stand-and-burn fight. After MB proc'd, I casted AM, and cut it off after one missile with a cast of AB (no macro, just started casting it). My standard cast time without procs as shown on Quartz is 1.8 seconds. With the Pushing the Limits buff, that drops to 1.6 seconds, also according to Quartz. The AB I used to cut off AM was cast in 1.6 seconds.

You guys are making it way more complicated than it needs to be. You don't need any fancy macros, and at current haste levels (I assume I'm on the low side compared to most mages in ICC, from what I've read) you don't even have to change your priority system. you can still fit in 4 AB's during the haste buff, provided your latency is low enough. At 1064 haste and ~100ms latency, I squeeze it in with about a half second left on the buff. Haste isn't recalculated mid-cast, so it doesn't matter if the buff ends mid-cast. Infact, it's ideal to have it end just after you start casting the spell, if you will not be able to cast another spell with said buff.
No, your info is completely incorrect. I just did the exact same test and clipping Arcane Missiles at all results in the first AB not getting the benefit of Pushing the Limit. That's why some people are turning to a nochanneling macro, which in this case may result in a dps gain.

I'm really not sure what's happening to you. My guess is that you're confused with a rolling PtL. Maybe you could capture your test and post it on youtube?

Last edited by Korey : 02/07/10 at 3:45 AM.

Offline
Old 02/07/10, 4:03 AM   #3471
Kevinally
Bald Bull
 
Kevinally's Avatar
 
Troll Mage
 
Trollbane
I'm not sure how you and I are getting two different answers from almost the same test. I'm definitely not rolling PtL. It clearly goes to 0sec just as I start casting my fourth AB, so the only way to "roll" it would be to go ABx3AM, which would be a waste of a perfectly good proc. I still disagree that a nochan macro would cause a DPS increase, though.

Yes, as long as I remember to, I'll fraps our 25 raid on tuesday (in an off-week right now). I'll even make Quartz FREAKING HUGE so there is no "well, is that a .6, or a .8".

United States Offline
Old 02/07/10, 5:46 AM   #3472
vukae
Von Kaiser
 
Human Mage
 
Defias Brotherhood (EU)
Originally Posted by Korey View Post
No, the buff applies after the MB ends.
No, your info is completely incorrect. I just did the exact same test and clipping Arcane Missiles at all results in the first AB not getting the benefit of Pushing the Limit.
Some simple testing I have done supports this. Below are some lines extracted from my combat log against the Ironforge dummy (I've removed extraneous information such as the damage lines and the hexadecimal codes). I'm not using any macros on my casts, and I took off my weapon (which has the Black Magic enchant) to prevent unwanted extra haste effects. My lag was sitting at about 25 ms.

2/7 10:03:47.212 SPELL_CAST_START "Vukae" "Arcane Blast" (B0)

2/7 10:03:49.460 SPELL_CAST_SUCCESS "Vukae" "Arcane Missiles" (M1)
2/7 10:03:49.850 SPELL_CAST_SUCCESS "Vukae" "Arcane Missiles" (M2)
2/7 10:03:50.216 SPELL_CAST_SUCCESS "Vukae" "Arcane Missiles" (M3)
2/7 10:03:50.472 SPELL_AURA_APPLIED "Vukae" "Vukae" "Pushing the Limit",BUFF (PtL)

2/7 10:03:50.473 SPELL_CAST_START "Vukae" "Arcane Blast" (B1)
2/7 10:03:52.359 SPELL_CAST_START "Vukae" "Arcane Blast" (B2)
2/7 10:03:54.035 SPELL_CAST_START "Vukae" "Arcane Blast" (B3)

I gained MBarr before blast B0 and I have clipped the AM channel after 3 missiles (M1-3) with the next AB (B1), and chain casted AB after that. Nominally I gain the PtL buff 1ms before the start of casting B1, however if you look at timing between the post-buff blasts: B2-B1 = 1.886s; B3-B2 = 1.676s. This is consistent with what Quartz was showing (1.9 and 1.7). So, I can only interpret this as B1 not benefitting from PtL.

Great Britain Offline
Old 02/07/10, 6:14 AM   #3473
Setia
Piston Honda
 
Human Mage
 
Ysera
I personnally had results similar to Korey, as have had most mages who posted on the issue on this board. Unless 3.2.2 changed something... but it didn't, I just tested again to make sure.

Also, the gain from a nochanneling macro isn't only to make sure your first AB gains PtL, however, it's also to make sure you get all five missiles. Losing the last missile is definitively a DPS loss; hence, even without PtL, depending on your clipping rate, the nochanneling macro might be an overall DPS gain (it's my case, especially if I use mousewheel casting or a "turbo" programmable button to minimize the impact of lag on the nochannelign macro).

Also, you don't need to wait until Festergut to test it. A training dummy works perfectly well.

Offline
Old 02/07/10, 1:57 PM   #3474
Saruk
Piston Honda
 
Troll Mage
 
Mal'Ganis
Originally Posted by Kevinally View Post
nochanneling macros are a DPS loss. This has already been discussed and proven.
This is not necessarily correct given that the major issue with AM (at least in my setup) is high latency. At high latency (300ms+) and/or highly variable latency Quartz doesn't seem to be that accurate. You can easily clip a AM missile with AB despite hitting the key directly in the red zone of the Quartz bar. This has something to do with how Quartz samples your latency.

Offline
Old 02/07/10, 3:08 PM   #3475
talchas
Von Kaiser
 
Troll Mage
 
Scarlet Crusade
It seems to be that Quartz will include server-side queuing as part of the "red zone" representation of your latency. This is correct for determining when you can start to cast a spell when you're casting a normal spell, but is incorrect when you're casting a channeled spell (it will clip the channel rather than queue).

Offline
Old 02/07/10, 7:44 PM   #3476
myth123
Glass Joe
 
Troll Mage
 
Tichondrius
Originally Posted by Arlie View Post
The 2p T10 buff will be applied as soon as you press your AM hotkey after MB procs, even if you move, or interrupt it right away, and never get an actual single missile off. You "consume" the MB simply by pressing your AM hotkey. It doesn't matter if you clip a missile or not, or clip all of them, you'll still get the "Pushing the Limit" haste buff.
I am almost certain this is incorrect. I just went to check at the dummies with the birthday suit+2xT10 and the first AB,with a clipped AM, casts at 2.3s and one after goes to 2.1.

By almost certain I mean something greater 95% but less than 100%. I am not willing to eliminate the possibility the server side cast time is 2.1s with the buff applied and the client simply doesn't know it. I doubt it though.

Last edited by myth123 : 02/07/10 at 7:50 PM.

Offline
Old 02/08/10, 8:19 AM   #3477
Morthoul
Von Kaiser
 
Morthoul's Avatar
 
Pandaren Mage
 
Shadowmoon
remove please

Last edited by Morthoul : 07/07/10 at 5:10 PM.

United States Offline
Old 02/09/10, 7:10 PM   #3478
Aestis
Von Kaiser
 
Aestis's Avatar
 
Troll Mage
 
Darkspear
The upshot of this clipping discussion, to me, is that it's best to wait briefly after the ABAM channel before casting an AB, ensuring that that first AB will benefit from 2t10. This would also have the benefit of negating any missile clipping. How long to wait, though, is what I what I'm wondering. I play with 100-200ms raid latency, and a nochanneling macro wouldn't really be feasible as it would delay all ABs by that amount.

2t10 speeds up our AB cast by roughly 215ms (with a 1.65s raid-hasted cast 1.65-1.65/1.15), so it would be beneficial to wait up to 215ms for the 2t10 buff to take effect. I wait to cast AB until I figure I'm about 50-100ms into the Quartz red zone, and I rarely clip missiles in raid. However, with that timing I also rarely find my first AB hasted.

I'd like to find out how long it takes 2t10 to take effect, and how/whether it relates to latency. More on this when I beat up the test dummy.

EDIT: It's been brought to my attention that [nochanneling] will only delay the cast directly following AM. D'oh. But again, the macro is still more useful for players with low lag relative to player cast-sniping accuracy.

Last edited by Aestis : 02/10/10 at 4:11 PM.

United States Offline
Old 02/10/10, 8:51 AM   #3479
Quantuvis
Von Kaiser
 
Troll Mage
 
Kazzak (EU)
Originally Posted by Aestis View Post
The upshot of this clipping discussion, to me, is that it's best to wait briefly after the ABAM channel before casting an AB, ensuring that that first AB will benefit from 2t10. This would also have the benefit of negating any missile clipping. How long to wait, though, is what I what I'm wondering. I play with 100-200ms raid latency, and a nochanneling macro wouldn't really be feasible as it would delay all ABs by that amount.
...snip
A [nochanneling] macro only protects channeled spells - you're not channeling your ABs, so your client is free to utilize the cast queue for successive ABs. The only time a [nochanneling] macro would harm you in your scenario is when casting a non-MB AM.
Personally I'm not sold on the [nochanneling] macro, I feel I've seen better results by "winging it", but I play with a stable 40-50ms.
I find it ridiculously hard to quantify though... for me it's a matter of personal preference.

Denmark Offline
Old 02/10/10, 11:01 AM   #3480
thach1ef
Glass Joe
 
Blood Elf Mage
 
Lightning's Blade
In regards to whether the first AB gets PtL after clipping AM. I've been reading the back and forth and I think you guys are thinking way too much into this. It's pretty simple to me.

PtL is a buff we get that is applied after MBAM is finished. Finished whether it's complete or if we cut it short. Right?

Well if we complete it, the game knows when it will be finished and is ready to proc that buff for us. However when we clip it and start casting an AB, the game was not ready for that. Therefore that AB is unhasted and the PtL will be on the next one.

It's impossible for programming to be a mind reader and expect you to clip the missiles. The whole reason you are clipping is because you are jumping the gun. Jumping the gun means you aren't going to have the PtL proc because you're casting your AB before the proc even starts.

I dunno. To me this is fairly straightforward.

Offline
Closed Thread

Go Back   Elitist Jerks » Class Mechanics » Mages

Thread Tools

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
The new Arcane after patch 2.3? Alvira The Dung Heap 2 11/07/07 4:17 AM
Arcane before 2-t5 and BT loots maxi The Dung Heap 1 10/03/07 6:26 AM
Playing an Arcane Mage Netherblade Class Mechanics 36 07/25/07 11:31 PM
Arcane Focus = +hit%? maxi Class Mechanics 2 04/10/07 10:46 AM