Elitist Jerks
Register
Blogs
Forums


Go Back   Elitist Jerks » Paladins

Closed Thread
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
Old 03/27/09, 1:36 AM   #2951
HamSlammer
Don Flamenco
 
HamSlammer's Avatar
 
Tauren Paladin
 
Emerald Dream
Originally Posted by flyingtoastr View Post
For real content, confirmed that SotM is not dealing the new coefficient damage. Don't trust any alliance ret parses you see until the next push. The tooltip is correct however.

Also, it seems that either we got snazzy new effects for our Auras or I'm just bugged.
Hopefully we can get some good parses from some Blood Elves, *coughArikahcough*, who aren't using the Venture Co. Libram, as it's still jacked.

As for Auras, I does seem like the ground effects are more... colorful if anything, less monochromatic it seems.

Offline
Old 03/27/09, 1:42 AM   #2952
flyingtoastr
Bald Bull
 
flyingtoastr's Avatar
 
Human Paladin
 
Draka
Originally Posted by HamSlammer View Post
As for Auras, I does seem like the ground effects are more... colorful if anything, less monochromatic it seems.
They're more colorful.

Actually, mine is simply superimposing the animation for Ret Aura over the other ones. It actually looks kinda cool with the "spikes" of Ret aura and the circles from Resists at the same time. Originally I had thought that by taking one of the improved talents (SaRet, Imp. Devo, Imp. Conc) it made your Auras display that animation over all your auras, but after a bit of fiddling that doesn't seem to be the case. Thus I have to assume it's just a bug.

And I was getting all hopeful that we'd be going all Warcraft III with our auras.

United States Offline
Old 03/27/09, 2:46 AM   #2953
greatrichie
Von Kaiser
 
Human Paladin
 
Terokkar
I BEEN LIED TOO!!!! SHENANIGANS!


You can delete this one then.

Last edited by greatrichie : 03/27/09 at 3:32 AM.

Offline
Old 03/27/09, 2:48 AM   #2954
HamSlammer
Don Flamenco
 
HamSlammer's Avatar
 
Tauren Paladin
 
Emerald Dream
Originally Posted by greatrichie View Post
From all the info from people I've talked to so far apparently SotM is a Seal dmg not buffed and Judgement dmg Nerfed situation, and SoB is a Seal dmg Buffed and Judgement dmg not nerfed, so either will probably be off from what the final will be. It'd be nice to get some more BE tests in to be sure, but the BE's I've talked to, Judgement dmg isn't lower and seal dmg is where it's supposed to be in this patch, from pictures and videos also.
Seal of Blood is definitely where it's supposed to be. Results from hitting the dummy on the PTR...



I was only buffed with Might and a Flask. Judgement of Blood is bugged as it's yet to be nerfed.

Last edited by HamSlammer : 03/27/09 at 4:27 AM.

Offline
Old 03/27/09, 3:44 AM   #2955
greatrichie
Von Kaiser
 
Human Paladin
 
Terokkar
Wait... was that PTR or Live? If thats PTR, then it's way over what mine were.


and I really doubt a flask and might = like, twice as much judgement dmg.

Last edited by greatrichie : 03/27/09 at 3:50 AM.

Offline
Old 03/27/09, 3:48 AM   #2956
HamSlammer
Don Flamenco
 
HamSlammer's Avatar
 
Tauren Paladin
 
Emerald Dream
Originally Posted by greatrichie View Post
Wait... was that PTR or Live? If thats PTR, then it's way over what mine were.
Definitely the PTR, I'll edit to clarify.

T8 got it's itemization shifted a bit, for the worse. The DPS stats appear to be a wash along with the loss of a bit of stamina.

Valorous Aegis Battlegear
+24 Strength
-40 Stamina
-16 Hit Rating
-21 Crit Rating
-3 Expertise Rating
-13 Haste Rating



Conqueror's Aegis Battlegear
+27 Strength
-41 Stamina
-15 Hit Rating
-19 Crit Rating
-4 Expertise Rating
-14 Haste Rating


Last edited by HamSlammer : 03/27/09 at 4:25 AM.

Offline
Old 03/27/09, 3:55 AM   #2957
beta4Life
Piston Honda
 
beta4Life's Avatar
 
Human Paladin
 
Greymane
That judgement damage is definitely higher than it should be. My toon is bugged to permanently have a shirt of uber, and I have those 239 legs putting my unbuffed AP at about 4k, and in ~15 minutes on a dummy my largest judgement crit was 5700ish, 9k with only self buffs (even when all the procs align) is much bigger than you should see after the nerf, I would say that is around the level I was seeing pre-nerf on a dummy self-buffed. I think Greatrichie is right, SoB looks like its judgement damage is not nerfed.

Your minimum is even more telling, i was seeing minimum's in the 1600's.

Here is a screenshot of me on a level 60 dummy, notice the very low judgements in comparison, while rocking over 4500 AP.



Offline
Old 03/27/09, 3:57 AM   #2958
greatrichie
Von Kaiser
 
Human Paladin
 
Terokkar
So Yeah... Belf Pallies get an uber SoB, with a buffed seal and unnerfed Judge.

Alli Pallies get the anti-uber SotM with Nerfed Jedges and Unbuffed seals. Awesome.

Offline
Old 03/27/09, 4:15 AM   #2959
beta4Life
Piston Honda
 
beta4Life's Avatar
 
Human Paladin
 
Greymane
That T8 change bugs me, yes strength is our best stat (all though possibly second to hit and expertise in 3.1, definitive numbers not out quite yet I would say), but due to the way itemization points scale adding more strength on strength heavy items doesn't actually necessarily make them better.

We know from gems that strength, crit, hit, expertise, and haste all cost the same amount when it comes to itemization, stam costs less (you get 1.5 stam per 1 pt of the dps stats). Running some quick napkin math, it cost us 79 "stat" points to gain 27 strength. Even though strength is extremely strong for us, if the new values if those 79 pts were thrown into the secondary stats we could have actually come out ahead from losing our stam, now it appears that we simply lose our stam, and get no real DPS gain in return. Just imagine, those 79 pts could have been something like 15 hit, 15 crit, 15 expertise, 15 haste, which would have easily been a higher dps return than just 27 strength.

After further inspection I also wonder if some pieces were simply over budget and may have been fixed. The chest lost stats across the board, -1 str, - 7 hit, -8 crit, +7 stam (???). 7 stam is no doubt cheaper than the 16 dps stats.

Offline
Old 03/27/09, 4:19 AM   #2960
Valdamos
Von Kaiser
 
Blood Elf Paladin
 
Thrall
Originally Posted by beta4Life View Post
That T8 change bugs me, yes strength is our best stat (all though possibly second to hit and expertise in 3.1, definitive numbers not out quite yet I would say), but due to the way itemization points scale adding more strength on strength heavy items doesn't actually necessarily make them better.

We know from gems that strength, crit, hit, expertise, and haste all cost the same amount when it comes to itemization, stam costs less (you get 1.5 stam per 1 pt of the dps stats). Running some quick napkin math, it cost us 79 "stat" points to gain 27 strength. Even though strength is extremely strong for us, if the new values if those 79 pts were thrown into the secondary stats we could have actually come out ahead from losing our stam, now it appears that we simply lose our stam, and get no real DPS gain in return. Just imagine, those 79 pts could have been something like 15 hit, 15 crit, 15 expertise, 15 haste, which would have easily been a higher dps return than just 27 strength.

After further inspection I also wonder if some pieces were simply over budget and may have been fixed. The chest lost stats across the board, -1 str, - 7 hit, -8 crit, +7 stam (???). 7 stam is no doubt cheaper than the 16 dps stats.
I was wondering the same thing. Admittedly it reminds me why Blizz sometimes hates showing their product before release. If we were shown the new stuff, and not the old stuff, we would be perfectly happy, but now that we've seen the old stuff we are upset that the new stuff has been nerfed. Does someone who knows the ilvl equation know how accurately these things are working right now for our T8?

Offline
Old 03/27/09, 4:24 AM   #2961
HamSlammer
Don Flamenco
 
HamSlammer's Avatar
 
Tauren Paladin
 
Emerald Dream
Judgement of Blood damage is bugged. It has yet to be nerfed. The Seal damage does appear to be working correctly though. Then, can we assume Judgement of the Martyr is dealing the correct damage but it's Seal is being wonky?

Originally Posted by beta4Life View Post
After further inspection I also wonder if some pieces were simply over budget and may have been fixed. The chest lost stats across the board, -1 str, - 7 hit, -8 crit, +7 stam (???). 7 stam is no doubt cheaper than the 16 dps stats.
This is my guess.

Offline
Old 03/27/09, 4:29 AM   #2962
greatrichie
Von Kaiser
 
Human Paladin
 
Terokkar
Originally Posted by HamSlammer View Post
Judgement of Blood damage is bugged. It has yet to be nerfed. The Seal damage does appear to be working correctly though. Then, can we assume Judgement of the Martyr is dealing the correct damage but it's Seal is being wonky?
Thats what it looks like... As much as I'd love to say the JoB numbers were right



Here's my live numbers, same gear, same lack of buffs, etc. Just testing judgements, and it's a pretty big gap between live and PTR.

Offline
Old 03/27/09, 4:30 AM   #2963
Pressure
Glass Joe
 
Gnome Warrior
 
Aman'Thul
A quick question on weapon speed

Quoted from first page of this thread:
Q: What does weapon speed do to us? Do we want slow or fast?
A: Slow. Every .1 speed slower is equal to ~30 DPS due to SoB not being normalized; so given a choice between a 3.4 203 dps 2h and a 3.8 203 dps 2h, the 3.8 would win.
I'm interested to know how the math behind this works out.
How does every 0.1 speed slower equal to ~30 dps more for SoB?
Could someone please enlighten me?

Last edited by Pressure : 03/27/09 at 4:34 AM. Reason: To make question easier to understand

Offline
Old 03/27/09, 4:41 AM   #2964
HamSlammer
Don Flamenco
 
HamSlammer's Avatar
 
Tauren Paladin
 
Emerald Dream
Originally Posted by Pressure View Post
How does every 0.1 speed slower equal to ~30 dps more for SoB?
Could someone please enlighten me?
Blood calculates damage based solely on your damage range. For auto-attacks, faster and slower weapons should even out in terms of SoB damage. However, CS and DS both proc Blood so having the slowest weapon with the highest DPS yields stronger Blood procs versus those from a faster weapon with equal DPS.

Offline
Old 03/27/09, 4:51 AM   #2965
Pressure
Glass Joe
 
Gnome Warrior
 
Aman'Thul
Originally Posted by HamSlammer View Post
Blood calculates damage based solely on your damage range. For auto-attacks, faster and slower weapons should even out in terms of SoB damage. However, CS and DS both proc Blood so having the slowest weapon with the highest DPS yields stronger Blood procs versus those from a faster weapon with equal DPS.
Your logic is clear, but I'm still not sure how every 0.1 sec slowness translates to ~30 dps increase.

Lets say I have 2 weapons:

Axe of Frozen Death
Binds when picked up
Two-Hand Axe
341 - 513 Damage Speed 3.60
(118.6 damage per second)

vs

Ingvar's Monolithic Cleaver
Binds when picked up
Two-Hand Axe
332 - 498 Damage Speed 3.20
(129.7 damage per second)

Which one would yield a higher dps?
According to this thread, the Axe of Frozen Death is slower than Ingvar's Monolithic Cleaver by 0.4 seconds.
This makes it ~[118.6+(4x30)]=238.6 dps, clearly way above that of the Cleaver's 129.7 dps.
Should I use the Axe over the Cleaver?

Offline
Old 03/27/09, 5:15 AM   #2966
beta4Life
Piston Honda
 
beta4Life's Avatar
 
Human Paladin
 
Greymane
Originally Posted by Pressure View Post
Your logic is clear, but I'm still not sure how every 0.1 sec slowness translates to ~30 dps increase.

Lets say I have 2 weapons:

Axe of Frozen Death
Binds when picked up
Two-Hand Axe
341 - 513 Damage Speed 3.60
(118.6 damage per second)

vs

Ingvar's Monolithic Cleaver
Binds when picked up
Two-Hand Axe
332 - 498 Damage Speed 3.20
(129.7 damage per second)

Which one would yield a higher dps?
According to this thread, the Axe of Frozen Death is slower than Ingvar's Monolithic Cleaver by 0.4 seconds.
This makes it ~[118.6+(4x30)]=238.6 dps, clearly way above that of the Cleaver's 129.7 dps.
Should I use the Axe over the Cleaver?

You are confusing DPS, with weapon DPS, a straight DPS boost (which is whaty the ~30 number is) cannot be compared to your weapon DPS.

In your specific case I would take the lower DPS but significantly slower weapon, weapon DPS isn't nearly as important as average damage (since DS, CS, seal, and judgment damage are all atleast partial based on weapon damage).


Bottom line? Look at the damage range on weapons, which ever has the highest average damage will be the better choice.

Offline
Old 03/27/09, 5:16 AM   #2967
Piiqo
Glass Joe
 
Blood Elf Paladin
 
Haomarush (EU)
Edit: Late

Offline
Old 03/27/09, 5:27 AM   #2968
Cerakona
Von Kaiser
 
Blood Elf Paladin
 
Moonglade (EU)
I take it these new fangled changes to SoB/SotM means that gems like Etched Monarch Topaz have more value until we acquire near-cap with hit... yeah, i know that "gem strength" is the usual, but considering the new changes, perhaps gemming pure strength initially in 3.1 might be slightly against our dps output now until we hit the caps needed. Obviously gemming none-stack stats (Haste, Expertise, Crit etc) is never seen in a good light again stack stats (Str, Agi etc), but from my take on these changes getting Exp and Hit cap is gonna be more important than it was 24 hours ago now. Please slap me on the face if my thinking has gone awry.

Offline
Old 03/27/09, 5:55 AM   #2969
Nisall
Piston Honda
 
Blood Elf Paladin
 
Dunemaul (EU)
Looking at those weapons, you are trying to apply lvl 80 spreadsheets to a lvl 70-73? It doesn't work that way since the rating to % conversion for hit/ArP/exp/crit/haste as vastly different depending on your level. All these stats have an influence on your dps return per 0.1 speed.

Offline
Old 03/27/09, 6:02 AM   #2970
SwordSa1nt
Von Kaiser
 
SwordSa1nt's Avatar
 
Blood Elf Paladin
 
Neptulon (EU)
Originally Posted by Cerakona View Post
I take it these new fangled changes to SoB/SotM means that gems like Etched Monarch Topaz have more value until we acquire near-cap with hit... yeah, i know that "gem strength" is the usual, but considering the new changes, perhaps gemming pure strength initially in 3.1 might be slightly against our dps output now until we hit the caps needed. Obviously gemming none-stack stats (Haste, Expertise, Crit etc) is never seen in a good light again stack stats (Str, Agi etc), but from my take on these changes getting Exp and Hit cap is gonna be more important than it was 24 hours ago now. Please slap me on the face if my thinking has gone awry.
Capping hit from gear only is easy even pre 3.1, correct me if im wrong but the hit cap wont be changed in 3.1?
Expertise will be harder, but still, gemming/enchanting for exp instead of STR/AP dosent seems reasonable to me. You wont get significant boost to expertise from this, but you will loose significant amount of str/ap.

Offline
Old 03/27/09, 6:09 AM   #2971
Valdamos
Von Kaiser
 
Blood Elf Paladin
 
Thrall
I agree its not all that hard to get hit capped from current gear, but considering until yesterday most of us had spent 0 effort getting hit capped, due to it not being necessary, that without farming for even more hit/expertise gear between now and 3.1, gemming for some hit/expertise initially might not be out of line. Especially considering getting hit capped will be even easier come 3.1,

Offline
Old 03/27/09, 6:55 AM   #2972
svirre
Glass Joe
 
Blood Elf Paladin
 
Twilight's Hammer (EU)
Trying out different specs and i'am pretty sure that i will go for imp devotion aura and 52 retri for pve.

Then i saw the new aura mastery. I read this as it will improve the effects of all other auras by 100% = retri aura's efect will be 6% damage and 6% melee and spellhaste for 10 seconds. Or do they mean that retriaura will just tick for 500 for 10 seconds instead of 250 or whatever it does.

Offline
Old 03/27/09, 6:58 AM   #2973
Ranjurm
Piston Honda
 
Draenei Paladin
 
Arathor
Unless they changed Aura Mastery in the latest build it only affects the baseline effects of the auras.

Offline
Old 03/27/09, 8:35 AM   #2974
Blutelf
Piston Honda
 
Blood Elf Paladin
 
Azshara (EU)
Do keep in mind that Improved Devotion Aura is not stacking with the Tree of Life aura of a resto druid.

Offline
Old 03/27/09, 9:21 AM   #2975
Thunderchylde
Glass Joe
 
Draenei Paladin
 
Frostwolf
I was thinking about the SoM/B changes and the fact that it still has 10% recoil on seal dmg... Given that SoM is borked, as is JoB, do we know that the recoil on seal dmg isn't also borked and is supposed to be absent?

(edit: clarified recoil)

Offline
Closed Thread

Go Back   Elitist Jerks » Paladins

Thread Tools

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
[Paladin] Offsetting Retribution Mimzy Class Mechanics 5 08/16/08 8:57 PM
[Paladin] Retribution - Question(s) bv23 Class Mechanics 31 07/11/07 8:56 AM
Retribution Paladin Raid DPS Questions Angfonz Class Mechanics 16 03/24/07 11:09 PM