Elitist Jerks
Register
Blogs
Forums


Go Back   Elitist Jerks » Class Mechanics » Rogues

Closed Thread
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
Old 12/05/11, 7:59 PM   #766
eylieen
Glass Joe
 
Human Rogue
 
Frostmourne
It's not so much the buff to assassination's damage, as it is the fact it's now simming ~1500dps better than combat in identical gear, whereas before combat was ahead in terms of single target. I'm just wondering if assassination is genuinely superior single target right now, since it wasn't before 4.3 launched.
Edit: ignore this, shadowcraft didn't change to combat glyphs after checking assassination, both specs are in a similar place to each other relative to before the buffs, I'm just dumb.

Last edited by eylieen : 12/05/11 at 9:46 PM.

Offline
Old 12/05/11, 8:10 PM   #767
RandomZero
Glass Joe
 
Undead Rogue
 
Vashj
Kind of an odd result for auto-reforge and gem.

And a link to my armory for comparison: Apathia - Vashj

Offline
Old 12/06/11, 5:54 AM   #768
Phrixos
Glass Joe
 
Undead Rogue
 
Burning Blade
I understand things are alittle screwy currently but when I load into shadow craft it shows a 1901.6 value for Heroic The Hungerer and 2387.1 for the Kiroptyric Sigil which is contrary to to the list of trinkets in the combat guide. Regardless of actual numbers, is shadowcraft modeling that correctly that the Kiroptyric Sigil should be valued over Heroic Hungerer ?

Offline
Old 12/06/11, 7:43 AM   #769
Artoxia
Von Kaiser
 
Night Elf Rogue
 
Frostwolf (EU)
For myself, running with hungerer (nhc), the heroic version of hungerer would be an increase of ~340 dps. Kyroptyric Sigil is calculed with an increase of ~1040 dps. Could this be right?

Offline
Old 12/06/11, 3:35 PM   #770
EastonS
Von Kaiser
 
EastonS's Avatar
 
Undead Rogue
 
Kazzak (EU)
Currently, Shadowcraft is Simulating normal mode No'Kaled to be a 2,142 DPS increase over Fear in my main hand. I thought that seemed big for weapon with less passive agility, no combat ratings and no stacking (albeit small) buff, and guessed the proc must be very frequent.

I lost a little bit of faith when I accidentally then put Fear (1.80) in my offhand over Vengeance, and saw a 2,010.7 dps increase.

For the record, this is in stock combat spec. Is this because Shadowcraft is assuming the +45% damage bonus is carrying over to the mainhand, even if Fear is in the offhand?

Great Britain Offline
Old 12/06/11, 4:03 PM   #771
Kortwa
Glass Joe
 
Kortwa's Avatar
 
Gnome Rogue
 
Proudmoore
Originally Posted by EastonS View Post
Currently, Shadowcraft is Simulating normal mode No'Kaled to be a 2,142 DPS increase over Fear in my main hand. I thought that seemed big for weapon with less passive agility, no combat ratings and no stacking (albeit small) buff, and guessed the proc must be very frequent.

I lost a little bit of faith when I accidentally then put Fear (1.80) in my offhand over Vengeance, and saw a 2,010.7 dps increase.

For the record, this is in stock combat spec. Is this because Shadowcraft is assuming the +45% damage bonus is carrying over to the mainhand, even if Fear is in the offhand?
It was stated above that Shadowcraft does not factor the +45% increase to SS and RvS in the EP calculations which is why the other weapons seem a lot stronger for combat.

I was swapping EP value with calculated dps from shadowcraft.

Last edited by Kortwa : 12/06/11 at 4:18 PM.

United States Offline
Old 12/06/11, 4:14 PM   #772
Moritsume
Glass Joe
 
Goblin Rogue
 
Arthas
Originally Posted by Kortwa View Post
It was stated above that Shadowcraft does not factor the +45% increase to SS and RvS in the EP calculations which is why the other weapons seem a lot stronger for combat.
Originally Posted by EastonS View Post
Currently, Shadowcraft is Simulating normal mode No'Kaled to be a 2,142 DPS increase over Fear in my main hand...

Originally Posted by Antiarc View Post
It's modeled in the DPS calculations, but not in the EP calculations. Given the exceptional nature of the items, I'm not inclined to do a ton more work to display 'em. It's easy enough to test their effect.
I think he was saying that the simulated DPS Shadowcraft was putting out shows No'Kaled to be a DPS increase over using Fear, not the EP values (which are what rank weapons when you click them to select one). This is backed up in Antiarc's post by saying that the DPS values are correct but the listed EP ranking(s) are incorrect.

This has been mentioned a few times, but until the Legendary pair, using same-ilvl weapons (No'Kaled) are a dps increase over using tier 1 daggers and possibly tier 2 daggers due to the low proc chance on the buff for Combat as well as more yet weaker Main Gauche procs and fewer Instant Poison procs.

Offline
Old 12/06/11, 4:17 PM   #773
Slackerkgs
Glass Joe
 
Orc Rogue
 
<KGS>
Boulderfist (EU)
EastonS is talking about DPS calculations, not EP. Antiarc posted in #759 that the 45% increase is calculated correctly in the DPS calculations. No'Kaled normal is around 700 DPS ahead of the other normal mode weapons with my gear set, so either the proc is in fact very strong, or something is not working correctly.

Just checked Wowhead and Fear is main hand only, so the fact that you get an increase over Vengeance when equipping it in the offhand is moot.

Offline
Old 12/06/11, 4:26 PM   #774
nextormento
Von Kaiser
 
Night Elf Rogue
 
Uldum (EU)
Curently yes, if you equip the mainhand on *any* slot it'll include the SS/RvS bonus (not like it'll let you, but if you could equip the mh in, say, the chest slot it'd still count). While the interface is very user friendly it's certainly not fool-proof: it lets you do plenty of useless combinations.

As for the VP sigil, the modeled cooldown is 60'' as reported in mmo-champion the day before the patch; you can math out its actual EP with the stat weights asuming a 16.6% uptime. While that's the most noticeable, there's plenty of other items to get updated (including Nokaled, which is modeled as proccing of main gauche as of now). I already updated my fork, but there's still more things to fix.

Last edited by nextormento : 12/06/11 at 4:31 PM.

Spain Offline
Old 12/06/11, 4:59 PM   #775
Phrixos
Glass Joe
 
Undead Rogue
 
Burning Blade
Okay, assuming my math is right for t13. Heroic The Hungerer- (433*2.83) + (1730*.166 uptime*1.87)= 1762.42 EP and the The Kiroptyric Sigil- (458*1.87) + (2290*.166 uptime*2.83)= 1932.26 EP. If this is wrong please feel free to correct my calculations.

Offline
Old 12/06/11, 7:09 PM   #776
• Aldriana
Mike Tyson
 
Night Elf Rogue
 
Doomhammer
Has anyone run across the erratic Sub behavior without using the legendary questline daggers? If you have, please let me know, as my working theory for what's going wrong involves miscalculation of the buff uptime.

On a related note:
@Antiarc: I've checked in a potential fix to that problem (assuming I'm right about what's causing it), so when you get a chance, please push my fix out and see if that lets things settle down a bit.

Offline
Old 12/06/11, 7:42 PM   #777
Pathal
Don Flamenco
 
Pathal's Avatar
 
Worgen Rogue
 
Doomhammer
That seems to do the trick.

Agility 3.90
Yellow Hit 1.86
Haste Rating 1.77
Expertise Rating 1.58
Crit Rating 1.44
Spell Hit 1.21
Strength 1.05
Mastery Rating 1.01
Attack Power 1.00
Hit Rating 0.93
Mainhand Dps 6.54
Offhand Dps 1.06

Offline
Old 12/06/11, 8:04 PM   #778
Xenden
Glass Joe
 
Xenden's Avatar
 
Pandaren Rogue
 
Bleeding Hollow
Originally Posted by Jaysen View Post
Unless I'm missing it somewhere way down the list, the raid finder version of [Wrath of Unchaining] is not present. The heroic version is missing as well.
The raid finder version is there, but it is valued lower than it should be. It seems like it is giving around 507 agi instead of the 780 that it actually gives.

United States Offline
Old 12/07/11, 8:42 PM   #779
escha
Glass Joe
 
Undead Rogue
 
Staghelm
Hey guys, thanks for the great shadowcraft tool. I have a quick question about how the gem optimizer works.

If you go to my character (Escha @ Staghelm-US - ShadowCraft) and load the 11-6 snapshot you should see 23813 dps. If you then press the optimize gems button the dps will fall to 23780. Hopefully links and saved snapshots work from any computer, but if it turns out to be stored in cookies I'll come back and list out the gear.

Does anyone know what causes this behavior? Is the optimizer maximizing a dps function over the variable set or is it simply picking the best gems based on your current EP values?

Thanks

Offline
Old 12/08/11, 4:14 AM   #780
n0point
Glass Joe
 
Night Elf Rogue
 
Sylvanas (EU)
Continuing the [Wrath of Unchaining] talk, I'm noticing some very sporadic tool behavior aroud this trinket.

Example A - combat spec, Wraith of Unchaining LFR ilvl equipped.


Drop 1 is noticed when I go from 390 WoU to 391 hungerer and seems much steeper than it should be. The following raise is noted when I go from 391 Hungerer to normal, 403 WoU, which the tool is showing to be a huge deal below the lfr version.

I get pretty much the same picture when specced sub - Wou LFR showing over 3k dps superior to Hungerer and about 2k dps better than WoU normal.

Offline
Closed Thread

Go Back   Elitist Jerks » Class Mechanics » Rogues

Thread Tools

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Rogue DPS Simulation Spreadsheet Mavanas Rogues 767 05/30/10 10:18 AM
Rogue Gear Spreadsheet Aldriana Class Mechanics 2892 08/03/08 5:10 AM
[Rogue] DPS Spreadsheet Ellos Class Mechanics 1595 01/12/08 5:32 PM
Rogue DPS Spreadsheet pf Class Mechanics 2735 07/20/07 5:42 PM
Rogue Spreadsheet tynan Public Discussion 2 12/06/06 5:30 AM