koaschten

You might want to try a spreadsheet to figure out what that would be like.

 

anticide

with a HaT spec (speed only mattering for deadly poison uptime), would a sinister revenge 171.1 dps 1.80 speed offhand dagger outdps a webbed death 156.4 dps 1.40 speed dagger? or would 5 stack DPs drop off enough to make the 1.40 speed better dps?

 

• Neto-

Why speed only matters for poison uptime...? You wouldn't run Wound?

 

anticide

you think double wound would outdps wound/deadly?

if you mean to deadly MH, i think the wound procs from finisher spam (with HaT) on MH would be better

 

• Neto-

Well, yes, but you really want your fast weapon to have Wound. It makes a pretty significant difference for Combat and I would guess for HAT too.

So yeah, OH the Sinister Revenge with Deadly.

 

anticide

oh, i think i explained it poorly

i use a kel'thuzad's reach for mainhand (i still hemo stuff with HaT, i'm not getting enough CPs to finisher every global). i wound it (i spam finishers/hemo enough to make it proc more than an OH would)

i'm currently using a sinister revenge for offhand (deadly poison) - i don't have any other daggers - and i was wondering if webbed death would be a superior OH (deadly poison). i stopped being lazy, checked the spreadsheet, and it seems webbed death would be 2-4 dps higher, nothing substantial. so i'll stick with this i suppose. edit: although i'm curious if at some level of expertise & hit rating the sinister revenge begins outdpsing the webbed death.


i'm also wondering if anyone has discovered what classes/specs, in general, crit the most with abilities: who are the best 4 people to have in my group for HaT? and whether pet abilities can proc HaT

edit: finally, i'm wondering the EP weight of expertise VS attack power/agility as HaT. considering you're dropping a finisher every 1-3 seconds and you lose 100% of the energy on a dodged evis/rupture, i figured expertise would have a high weight - high enough to socket it until cap?

 

Drumaddikk

Please forgive me for sounding uber-noobish, but what exactly does it mean by "Hit is about 1.8 below the yellow hit cap"?
1.8 what? Yellow Hit Cap?

Or am I just having a huge brain fart?

 

MissnL1nK

If you are below the yellow hit cap (132), then the value per hit is 1.8.

 

• Neto-

The yellow (special attacks) hit cap is 132.

 

saedo

It would be as good as 2 saronite shivs can do for you? Spreadsheet it if you want to compare to other daggers.

edit: oops missed reading all the posts i missed

 

sephfiroth

Quick question: Do Instant poison crits count as Melee or Spell? I would assume Spell.

 

saedo

Yes spell mechanics.

 

Bloodkill

just curious, why is it that AP is valued a bit more than agi on the spreadsheet? I always thought agi would be better, especially as mutilate.

 

Greggto

Hello, I have a few simple questions.

1. To maximize dps on trash, do you guys use wound on MH and deadly on OH?
2. fast dagger on MH and slower on OH is still the way to go right? I armoried aldriana and i saw him using slow on MH
3. Suppose you got 3 stacks of deadly poison on a mob, do you envenom or eviscerate?
4. Are there any addons to help watch the SnD and HfB?
5. Aldriana gemmed for expertise even though AP is better..should I do the same until I get a decent amount of expertise.

 

saedo

1. Difference is probably not much on trash. Maybe go with Wound and Instant if you want more burst
2. Speed just another stat. I'm guessing Aldriana has his slow in the mh is because it's the only one he got Berserking on.
4. I use ClassTimers for timers, there are others out there.
5. I only see a couple of expertise gems on "older" gear, T6 belt, blue shoulders. JC skilling put to use?

 

songster

If you're soloing / levelling and therefore spending most of your time in front of the mob, expertise is the best stat, period - the fact that it reduces parry as well as dodge doubles its effectiveness when in front. While levelling, you want expertise in every socket you have, if you can be bothered to change gems on temporary kit. I imagine Aldriana has some left over from this process.

 

Cicatriz

What rotation have you guys been using for Combat?

I usually just start out with 1 CP SnD, 5 CP Evis (I spec'd 3/3 Imp, and have the glyph, and I'm not spec'd into serrated blades), and then after that I'll just SS til SnD wears off, and then refresh it with whatever I have, then 5 points again evis, usually can 5 points again evis, and then I'll have to refresh with 1-2 CP SnD.

Just curious because back in BC, even with Potency procs there was still a semi-consistent rotation you could use. Now with the 25% energy buff + Potency + SS glyph, I can't find something consistent that I could follow decently.

So I was just wondering what you guys use.

Thanks!

 

Kumar

Is this for Levelling or raid DPS?

For Raid DPS: http://elitistjerks.com/f78/t37183-pocket_guide_wotlk/

You want to use Rupture, for a Xs/Yr rotation, or do a Xs/Yr/Ye roation with SS/Rupture/SnD glyphs.

 

Cicatriz

I'm using SnD, SS, and Evis glyph. I remember hearing that WITH 3/3 Imp. Evis AND the glyph, Evis > Rupture.

The pocket guide says to just do a Xs/Yr rotation, mine will probably be Ye though, unless you think I should respec to pick up 3/3 Ruth and 2/2 Blood Splatter instead of 3/3 Evis?

Edit: It's for Raid/Heroic DPS

 

zetto

How is Muti doing in live now?
Only seen dps meters from Beta

Im combat speced atm fist/sword..
wonder if its worth to try get some nice daggers and spec muti to improve dps

 

coderego

Is there a dps spreadsheet that gives gear upgrade suggestions like aldriana's Rogue Gear Spreadsheet did?

 

Leto

1) Using wound/instant would maximize dps on trash. Trash dies too fast for deadly to be optimally effective, and you also switch targets frequently. When I do dailies, I use wound/instant.

2) fast is better for sustained fights, as there is plenty of opportunity for the average fa procs to appear. For very short fights, grinding, etc, the harder hitting dagger in the mh would yield larger mutilates. I know when I do dailies I use my slower dagger in the mh (why it appears that way in my armory profile), so maybe that's the same reason Aldriana did the same?

3) I don't have the math handy, but I'd say envenom, considering envenom scales with ap the same way regardless of cp usage, while eviscerate scales worse the fewer cp you use.

4) I personally use needtoknow and find it wonderful. Slicecommander also seemed good, since it has audible warnings, but I have not tried it.

5) The spreadsheet values expertise highly below the cap, but it doesn't model exactly, so the stat weightings might not take into account the effect on your cycle as ideally as possible. Capping expertise first, even though theoretically not as large an improvement as stacking ap, smooths out your cycles and allows you to wait longer to envenom without fear of a dodge. I assume it is his personal preference, and also gem choices on items you'll soon replace isn't the most critical of decisions, so those might have been the gems available to him... though they are blue gems, so I'd say it's more likely the choice of expertise was intentional.

Rogue at heart.

 

Kumar

Rupture will provide you more DPS.

 

Cicatriz

Thank you sir! Will do.

Edit: On a side-note, what have you guys found to be a better in terms of Raid/Heroic DPS. Lethality Combat, or Serrated Blades? I know later on once rogues are back up to 30% crit unbuffed that lethality should provide more in terms of DPS since it scales and Serrated Blades doesn't. But has anyone tried to hone in on that magic number or can guess when taking SB won't be worth it?

 

Drumaddikk

The Imp FF from Druids is nerfed right? So we cant add that to the "Hit Cap"?