|
|
|
|
01/10/11, 7:03 AM
|
#1 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Glass Joe
|
[Enhancement] BiS gear and set-up discussion (4.3 and onward)
The purpose of this post is to provide the current best-in-slot gearing setup for an Enhancement Shaman. It will be be kept as up to date as possible.
This is not intended to discuss or debate which race or professions are the best for an Enhancement Shaman, and only to discuss our basic best in slot setup including glyphs. For other Enhancement related discussion, refer to this thread: [Enhancement] 4.3 - At least your old Axe is good for transmog! This list obviously isn't final. Please keep in mind that while I believe this setup to be the best currently available in game, I am human and have not tested every possible setup. If I have made mistakes, spelling errors, or there's an error in a config file, or you have any other questions or comments, send me a PM rather than cluttering up the thread. If you believe you have a gear, enchant, gem, reforge, imbue or glyph or talent setup that is superior, you'll need to simulate your setup and provide data supporting your claim, keeping a few things consistent with what is outlined here. For the sake of consistency, most parameters required will be similar to those outlined in the 3.3 BiS discussion thread by Vespasian and Rava. Race: Must be Tauren. Other races provide a dps increase. Professions: Must be Alchemy and Enchanting. They do not interfere with normal enchants and provide +80 agility each. Mana: Simulating mana is not necessary, we are not limited by it. It's fine if you do, the results should be identical either way. Do not use Shamanistic Rage as soon as available. Simulation Time: 5000 hours Combat Length: 7 minutes Combat Variation: 35% Reaction Time: 230-260. Talents: This is the talent setup currently being used. Please note that Shamanistic Rage will be considered a required talent point. PLEASE INCLUDE CONFIG FILE AND DPS REPORT WITH YOUR POST, as well as any and all changes you made from those found under the item list. Agility main hand: With 4.3, spell power weapons are dead. We are not likely to see them compete again in the future. I don't have a config/dps report to give yet, but wanted to update for 4.3 as quickly as possible, so until I'm able to provide them, if you have any setups you believe to be better, please PM me instead of cluttering up this thread unless you can provide significant data supporting it. There is a lot of potential for different setups to have very similar output this tier, as several of the highest agility items also have very weak secondary stat combinations, namely Sporebeard Gauntlets, Belt of the Beloved Companion, Treads of Dormant Dreams and Signet of Grasping Mouths. Spiritwalker's Grips, or VP gear in the other 3 cases may be very competitive. It's also entirely possible that some setups will go as high as 60 points over the spell hit cap. Hit beyond the cap is often better than Haste Rating. Chardev profile: chardev 9
Stat values (DPS) These are the stat values used with the below Config file. Yours will be different. Sim it yourself for your own character for best results.
DPS Report and config file:  ← Click HereLast edited by Ashunera : 05/13/12 at 9:13 PM. Reason: Updated 4.3..finally |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
|
01/10/11, 8:16 AM
|
#2 | |
|
Don Flamenco
|
Also exchanging the Feral Spirit Glyph with the Flametongue Glyph increases the DPS by around 200 with the current version 2.3.0 of the sim. |
|
|
|
|
01/10/11, 10:49 AM
|
#5 |
|
Glass Joe
|
Last edited by Israfel : 01/11/11 at 1:53 AM. |
|
|
|
|
01/10/11, 11:19 AM
|
#6 |
|
Glass Joe
|
|
|
|
|
|
01/10/11, 1:51 PM
|
#7 |
|
Glass Joe
|
|
|
|
|
|
01/10/11, 4:56 PM
|
#8 | |
|
Glass Joe
|
Ashunera I understand that you are listing the BiS but I only have one issue:
Last edited by Jessamy : 01/10/11 at 5:14 PM. Reason: plagiarism is bad |
|
|
|
|
|
01/10/11, 5:11 PM
|
#9 |
|
Struck by Diax's Rake
|
Last edited by Jessamy : 01/10/11 at 5:16 PM. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
01/11/11, 7:09 AM
|
#10 | |
|
Piston Honda
|
Thank you for getting something like this going again; I had considered doing so myself having recently returned to the class. It is disappointing that the thread began at time when FT is being re-designed- it will create a lot of confused Shaman. I would probably make the disclaimer relating to the upcoming nerf a touch clearer, lest the sort of posting above continues to ensue.
I think your decision relating to talents is off the mark. Certain talents and enchants (think runspeed) provide varying levels of utility, and it’s up to the player to make a judgment about what utility is most valuable at different times and in different circumstances. From my old post:
Also, the priority queue looks rather static as you have written it. I would suggest a table format (as with the other dynamic variables) to encourage people to tweak this queue. Similar with the talent spec listing. Finally, I think there is value in a post explaining methodology so that the lay-man can at least know the tools that are being used and can try it for themselves (I for one do not know how you managed to export your re-forged Chardev page to enhsim- if it is a manual process human error can creep in, making your cross-checking of people’s submissions take a lot longer). Perhaps a mod could squeeze in another post under your OP allowing you to do this As you can tell, much of this is personal preference so feel free to discard as much or as little as you like. Best of luck with the thread- I look forward to following the discussion. |
|
|
|
||
|
|
|
|
01/11/11, 7:19 AM
|
#11 | |
|
Glass Joe
|
A slow caster weapon is preferred, but the weapon speed doesn't mean quite as much as the weapon's spell power. The vast majority are 1.8 speed and very few 359+ have weapon DPS over the 72.4 mark.
For those curious, dual [Crul'korak, the Lightning's Arc] is the best main and off-hand if you refuse to use a spell power weapon. It's hard to tell when exactly a caster weapon pulls ahead by a noticeable amount, but once you get to a point where you're looking for Mastery gear instead of Hit gear (or roughly around full 346 blues), a caster weapon starts to pull ahead by a few hundred dps. The only way to know for sure which setup is best for you with any given gear setup is to sim it. Keep in mind a target dummy will not provide you with accurate results - raid buffs significantly increase our spell damage output, while we bring the vast majority of melee buffs on our own. The disparity between Caster and Agility weapons only increases as you acquire more gear as well, and in full heroic quality gear, the switch to Crul'korak from Andoros (and the resulting switch to Windfury due to matched weapon speeds) will net you a 1000 DPS loss at least. 4.0.6 Shaman patch notes (not complete, and official forums are down as of this post) have a "fix" to Flametongue Weapon damage that will reduce this disparity, but I suspect it will not be enough to put Agility weapons ahead.
Last edited by Ashunera : 01/11/11 at 7:52 AM. |
|
|
|
|
|
01/11/11, 7:43 AM
|
#12 | |
|
Piston Honda
|
Encounters, off the top of my head (that I have experience with, I'm sure there are more in heroic), that contain very high, and very concentrated raid damage (or single target damage), and therefore encounters that using SR will likely prevent you from dying: Heroic Omnitron Defense System - on Aquiring Target, (shadow infused) Lightning Conductor Heroic Halfus - Mitigate raid damage on the pull, and Furious Roar Nefarian - Massive raid damage every 10% of Nefarian's health, I forget what it's called Conclave of the Winds - Nezir's Sleet Storm Heroic Maloriak - Red phase fire breath, and dark phase for mitigating puddle damage Chimeron - Fued Just about every other raid encounter has a point where using SR situationally is encouraged, however these have absolute cut and dry points where using it is almost required, and if it's not up, some other cooldown is going to be needed (stoneclaw, bubble, raid wall, tranq etc). I realize that this is a theoretical exercise in maximizing damage, but this isn't the type of thing that should be suggested under any circumstances. |
|
|
|
|
|
01/11/11, 8:01 AM
|
#13 |
|
Glass Joe
|
Ashunera I have a couple questions about your config file vs your chardev page.
Your config file has: Str: 145 Agi: 4699 Int: 309 Melee Crit: 28.63 Attack Power: 10587 Spell Power: 8856 Spell Crit: 10.31 Spell Hit: 17.02 While your CharDev with your gear on it has: Str: 156 Agi: 4525 Int: 320 Melee Crit: 24.49 Attack Power: 10489 Spell Power: 7761 Spell Crit: 10.33 Spell Hit: 17.86 Those are the numbers I found off from your gear list and your config. Was curious as to where you got the 174 Agility, 4.14% Melee Crit, 98 more attack power, and 1,095 more spell power while missing out on 11 Int, 0.03% Spell Crit(from the 11 Int), and 11 Str. Is there some modification going on from your CharDev to EnhSim? When I input the corrected stats from CharDev to Enhsim I'm getting: DPS Output  EnhSim version 2.3.0
................................................................................
MH:
miss 738331 6.47%
dodge 0 0.00%
glancing 2739392 24.02%
hit 3523586 30.89%
crit 4404823 38.62%
average ap 15674.45
clip 0 0.00%
MH Flametongue:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 8466333 75.69%
crit 2719359 24.31%
cooldown 1320683 10.56%
average sp 13701.62
MH Storsmtrike:
miss 0 0.00%
dodge 0 0.00%
hit 1078552 58.66%
crit 760022 41.34%
average ap 15634.78
MH Unleashed Weapon Flametongue:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 837995 75.73%
crit 268601 24.27%
average sp 13712.39
OH:
miss 654171 6.48%
dodge 0 0.00%
glancing 2421044 23.99%
hit 3116863 30.89%
crit 3898827 38.64%
average ap 15670.80
clip 0 0.00%
OH Flametongue:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 7340093 75.68%
crit 2358432 24.32%
cooldown 3229374 24.98%
average sp 13699.44
OH Stormstrike:
miss 0 0.00%
dodge 0 0.00%
hit 1073952 58.41%
crit 764622 41.59%
average ap 15665.84
OH Unleashed Weapon Flametongue:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 838532 75.78%
crit 268064 24.22%
average sp 13712.39
Earth Shock:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 647770 40.73%
crit 942684 59.27%
average sp 13690.70
Flame Shock:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 730243 75.70%
crit 234405 24.30%
average sp 13723.71
dots hit 4518396 75.68%
dots crit 1451950 24.32%
average dot sp 13754.92
Lava Lash:
miss 0 0.00%
dodge 0 0.00%
hit 965935 58.45%
crit 686656 41.55%
average ap 15633.19
Lightning Bolt:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 582540 31.06%
crit 1292895 68.94%
average sp 13715.90
Lightning Shield:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 977403 40.77%
crit 1420219 59.23%
average sp 13710.61
Spirit Wolves:
miss 0 0.00%
dodge 0 0.00%
glancing 1706332 23.98%
hit 5196568 73.03%
crit 212616 2.99%
average ap 15984.64
Searing Totem:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 8115799 75.68%
crit 2608718 24.32%
average sp 13687.99
Searing Flames:
hit 3567511 75.68%
crit 1146250 24.32%
average sp 13679.00
Trinket1 Damage:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 786664 75.72%
crit 252219 24.28%
Maelstrom Weapon:
PPM 34.65
efficiency 90.21%
flurry uptime 78.34%
elemental devastation uptime 94.07%
UW Flametongue uptime 23.36%
mh enchant uptime 27.31%
oh enchant uptime 31.22%
stormstrike debuff uptime 98.99%
flame shock uptime 88.87%
lightning shield uptime 100.00%
searing totem uptime 99.77%
searing flame uptime 92.06%
MRPS without overregen
mana regen 0.08 0.03%
mp5 27.56 10.83%
replenishment 30.82 12.12%
unrelenting storm 0.00 0.00%
primal wisdom 195.97 77.02%
shamanistic rage 0.00 0.00%
mana potion 0.00 0.00%
misc 0.00 0.00%
DPS PPM MPS
white 2848.61 11.42% 71.66
flametongue 4086.29 16.38% 69.61
searing flames 995.67 3.99% 15.71
stormstrike 1088.76 4.36% 6.13 47.86 20.82%
lava lash 3410.39 13.67% 5.51 21.51 9.36%
searing totem 3161.95 12.68% 1.09 7.47 3.25%
earth shock 1262.65 5.06% 5.30 93.16 40.53%
flame shock 1763.21 7.07% 3.22 53.37 23.21%
direct damage 475.45 26.96% 3.22
dot tick 1287.77 73.04% 19.90
lightning bolt 2630.76 10.55% 6.25 0.00 0.00%
lightning shield 1170.35 4.69% 0.14 0.00 0.00%
spirit wolves 404.17 1.62% 0.56 6.51 2.83%
unleashed elements 1589.78 6.37% 3.69 25.21 10.97%
MH Flametongue 794.98 50.01% 3.69
OH Flametongue 794.79 49.99% 3.69
Trinket1 530.52 2.13% 3.46
DPS 24943.12
MPS 229.88
MP2min 27585.05
MRPS 808.45
Out of mana time 0.00%
elapsed simulation time: 5000.00h
elapsed real time: 26.08s
simulation speed: 690236x
Config: ### Saved by v2.3.0 of EnhSimGUI config_version 2.3.0 simulation_time 5000 simulation_time_combatlog 300 combat_length 7 report_count 80 threads 1 combat_length_rng_factor 0.35 min_lag 230 max_lag 260 simulate_mana 1 cast_sr_on_cooldown 0 ep_precision 2 ep_base_stat ap ep_ap 200 ep_crit_rating 100 ep_hit_rating -100 ep_expertise_rating -100 ep_haste_rating 100 ep_mastery_rating 100 ep_spellpower 115 ep_dps 57 ep_mana 1200 ep_spirit 100 ep_mp5 100 ep_intellect 100 ep_agility 100 ep_strength 100 mh_auto_attack 1 oh_auto_attack 1 use_bloodlust 1 always_bloodlust_wolves 0 cast_lvb_only_if_fs_active 1 cast_fs_only_if_dots_left 1 cast_magma_only_if_ticks_left 1 cast_searing_only_if_ticks_left 1 cast_sr_only_if_mana_left 0 use_mana_potion_if_mana_left 1000 necrotic_touch 0 necrotic_touch_heroic 0 gloves_enchant - cloak_enchant - ring_proc - weapon_set_proc - rotation_priority_count 8 rotation_priority1 ST rotation_priority2 LL rotation_priority3 FS_UEF rotation_priority4 MW5_LB rotation_priority5 UE rotation_priority6 SS rotation_priority7 ES rotation_priority8 SW aoe_rotation_priority_count 0 fight_name standard_single_target miss 8.00 dodge 6.50 glancing 24.00 armor 11977 spell_miss 17.00 nature_resistance 0 fire_resistance 0 frost_resistance 0 arcane_resistance 0 shadow_resistance 0 additional_targets 0 additional_target_percent 0.00 additional_target_level 85 armor_debuff 12.0/12.0 physical_vulnerability_debuff 4.0/4.0 melee_haste_buff 10.0/10.0 crit_chance_buff 5.0/5.0 attack_power_buff_multiplier 10.0/10.0 spell_haste_buff 5.0/5.0 spell_crit_chance_debuff 5.0/5.0 spell_damage_debuff 8.0/8.0 spellpower_buff 10.0/10.0 percentage_damage_increase 3.0/3.0 stat_multiplier 5.0/5.0 agi_and_strength_buff 549/549 mana_buff 2126/2126 mana_regen_buff 326/326 replenishment 1 water_shield 0 mixology 1 flask_elixir flask_of_the_winds guardian_elixir - potion potion_of_the_tolvir food skewered_eel ############################################################################### ### Everything in the section below can be replaced by information obtained ### ### from your paper doll stats or exported by the ShockAndAwe addon ### ############################################################################### race tauren mh_speed 2.3 oh_speed 2.6 mh_dps 72.4 oh_dps 521.73 mh_crit 24.49 oh_crit 24.49 mh_hit 20.52 oh_hit 20.52 mh_expertise_rating 541 oh_expertise_rating 541 ap 10489 melee_haste 3.98 str 156 agi 4525 int 320 spi 244 mastery_rating 1963 spellpower 7761 spell_crit 10.33 spell_hit 17.86 spell_haste 3.98 max_mana 27950 mp5 0 mh_imbue flametongue oh_imbue flametongue mh_enchant landslide oh_enchant landslide mh_weapon mace oh_weapon axe trinket1 darkmoon_card_hurricane trinket2 fluid_death set_bonus1 t11_battlegear_4 set_bonus2 - set_bonus3 - metagem relentless_earthstorm_diamond glyph_prime1 stormstrike glyph_prime2 flametongue_weapon glyph_prime3 lava_lash glyph_major1 - glyph_major2 - glyph_major3 - armor_type_bonus 1 primary_talent enhancement elemental_weapons 2/2 focused_strikes 3/3 improved_shields 0/3 elemental_devastation 3/3 flurry 3/3 static_shock 3/3 improved_fire_nova 2/2 searing_flames 3/3 frozen_power 0/2 shamanistic_rage 1/1 unleashed_rage 2/2 improved_lava_lash 2/2 maelstrom_weapon 3/3 convection 0/2 concussion 3/3 call_of_flame 2/2 reverberation 2/2 elemental_precision 0/3 elemental_focus 0/1 elemental_oath 0/2 lava_flows 0/3 storm_earth_and_fire 0/3 elemental_mastery 0/1 feedback 0/3 lava_surge 0/2 Last edited by Saveric : 01/11/11 at 8:07 AM. Reason: Spell Hit. |
|
|
|
|
01/11/11, 10:04 AM
|
#15 |
|
Piston Honda
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
01/11/11, 11:00 AM
|
#16 |
|
Deeper Shade of Blue
|
|
|
|
|
|
01/11/11, 11:17 AM
|
#17 |
|
Glass Joe
|
Using the exact same gear setup and parameters as the original poster I was able to obtain ~450 dps increase by changing talents slightly to; Talent Calculator - World of Warcraft.
DPS Report: EnhSim version 2.3.0
................................................................................
MH:
miss 738938 6.48%
dodge 0 0.00%
glancing 2739486 24.02%
hit 3527839 30.93%
crit 4399265 38.57%
average ap 15676.67
clip 0 0.00%
MH Flametongue:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 8479636 75.66%
crit 2727249 24.34%
cooldown 1329502 10.61%
average sp 13702.39
MH Storsmtrike:
miss 0 0.00%
dodge 0 0.00%
hit 1096650 58.65%
crit 773147 41.35%
average ap 15631.26
MH Unleashed Weapon Flametongue:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 834329 75.67%
crit 268304 24.33%
average sp 13714.55
OH:
miss 653948 6.48%
dodge 0 0.00%
glancing 2422823 24.01%
hit 3122714 30.95%
crit 3890892 38.56%
average ap 15672.92
clip 0 0.00%
OH Flametongue:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 7333649 75.67%
crit 2358102 24.33%
cooldown 3262659 25.19%
average sp 13701.27
OH Stormstrike:
miss 0 0.00%
dodge 0 0.00%
hit 1092763 58.44%
crit 777034 41.56%
average ap 15662.20
OH Unleashed Weapon Flametongue:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 835031 75.73%
crit 267602 24.27%
average sp 13714.55
Earth Shock:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 554170 40.69%
crit 807887 59.31%
average sp 13684.23
Flame Shock:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 717967 75.68%
crit 230756 24.32%
average sp 13719.91
dots hit 4424575 75.66%
dots crit 1423319 24.34%
average dot sp 13751.33
Lava Lash:
miss 0 0.00%
dodge 0 0.00%
hit 964868 58.54%
crit 683316 41.46%
average ap 15641.84
Lightning Bolt:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 584222 31.12%
crit 1293223 68.88%
average sp 13715.77
Lightning Shield:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 989426 40.82%
crit 1434399 59.18%
average sp 13710.41
Spirit Wolves:
miss 0 0.00%
dodge 0 0.00%
glancing 1708956 23.98%
hit 5202952 73.02%
crit 213754 3.00%
average ap 15985.71
Searing Totem:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 8119774 75.65%
crit 2613915 24.35%
average sp 13689.42
Searing Flames:
hit 3581691 75.65%
crit 1152918 24.35%
average sp 13679.28
Trinket1 Damage:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 788690 75.73%
crit 252731 24.27%
Maelstrom Weapon:
PPM 34.73
efficiency 90.11%
flurry uptime 78.32%
elemental devastation uptime 93.42%
UW Flametongue uptime 22.55%
mh enchant uptime 27.42%
oh enchant uptime 31.34%
stormstrike debuff uptime 98.96%
flame shock uptime 87.13%
lightning shield uptime 100.00%
searing totem uptime 99.76%
searing flame uptime 92.30%
MRPS without overregen
mana regen 0.11 0.04%
mp5 26.46 10.98%
replenishment 29.53 12.26%
unrelenting storm 0.00 0.00%
primal wisdom 184.79 76.71%
shamanistic rage 0.00 0.00%
mana potion 0.00 0.00%
misc 0.00 0.00%
DPS PPM MPS
white 2847.24 11.22% 71.65
flametongue 4212.25 16.59% 69.66
searing flames 1033.66 4.07% 15.78
stormstrike 1106.97 4.36% 6.23 48.68 22.50%
lava lash 3501.84 13.79% 5.49 21.45 9.91%
searing totem 3260.35 12.84% 1.09 7.47 3.45%
earth shock 1092.52 4.3% 4.54 79.78 36.87%
flame shock 1746.98 6.88% 3.16 52.48 24.26%
direct damage 472.48 27.05% 3.16
dot tick 1274.50 72.95% 19.49
lightning bolt 2660.79 10.48% 6.26 0.00 0.00%
lightning shield 1340.18 5.28% 0.14 0.00 0.00%
spirit wolves 404.80 1.59% 0.56 6.51 3.01%
unleashed elements 1632.23 6.43% 3.68 25.12 11.61%
MH Flametongue 816.23 50.01% 3.68
OH Flametongue 816.00 49.99% 3.68
Trinket1 547.74 2.16% 3.47
DPS 25387.55
MPS 216.38
MP2min 25965.35
MRPS 814.11
Out of mana time 0.00%
elapsed simulation time: 5000.00h
elapsed real time: 15.33s
simulation speed: 1174321x
config_version 2.3.0 simulation_time 5000 simulation_time_combatlog 300 combat_length 7 report_count 80 threads 1 combat_length_rng_factor 0.35 min_lag 230 max_lag 260 simulate_mana 1 cast_sr_on_cooldown 0 ep_precision 2 ep_base_stat ap ep_ap 200 ep_crit_rating 100 ep_hit_rating -100 ep_expertise_rating -100 ep_haste_rating 100 ep_mastery_rating 100 ep_spellpower 115 ep_dps 57 ep_mana 1200 ep_spirit 100 ep_mp5 100 ep_intellect 100 ep_agility 100 ep_strength 100 mh_auto_attack 1 oh_auto_attack 1 use_bloodlust 1 always_bloodlust_wolves 0 cast_lvb_only_if_fs_active 1 cast_fs_only_if_dots_left 1 cast_magma_only_if_ticks_left 1 cast_searing_only_if_ticks_left 1 cast_sr_only_if_mana_left 0 use_mana_potion_if_mana_left 1000 necrotic_touch 0 necrotic_touch_heroic 0 gloves_enchant - cloak_enchant - ring_proc - weapon_set_proc - rotation_priority_count 8 rotation_priority1 ST rotation_priority2 LL rotation_priority3 FS_UEF rotation_priority4 MW5_LB rotation_priority5 UE rotation_priority6 SS rotation_priority7 ES rotation_priority8 SW aoe_rotation_priority_count 0 fight_name standard_single_target miss 8.00 dodge 6.50 glancing 24.00 armor 11977 spell_miss 17.00 nature_resistance 0 fire_resistance 0 frost_resistance 0 arcane_resistance 0 shadow_resistance 0 additional_targets 0 additional_target_percent 0.0 additional_target_level 85 armor_debuff 12.0/12.0 physical_vulnerability_debuff 4.0/4.0 melee_haste_buff 10.0/10.0 crit_chance_buff 5.0/5.0 attack_power_buff_multiplier 10.0/10.0 spell_haste_buff 5.0/5.0 spell_crit_chance_debuff 5.0/5.0 spell_damage_debuff 8.0/8.0 spellpower_buff 10.0/10.0 percentage_damage_increase 3.0/3.0 stat_multiplier 5.0/5.0 agi_and_strength_buff 549/549 mana_buff 2126/2126 mana_regen_buff 326/326 replenishment 1 water_shield 0 mixology 1 flask_elixir flask_of_the_winds guardian_elixir - potion potion_of_the_tolvir food skewered_eel race tauren mh_speed 2.3 oh_speed 2.6 mh_dps 72.4 oh_dps 521.73 mh_crit 24.49 oh_crit 24.49 mh_hit 20.52 oh_hit 20.52 mh_expertise_rating 541 oh_expertise_rating 541 ap 10489 melee_haste 3.98 str 156 agi 4525 int 320 spi 244 mastery_rating 1963 spellpower 7761 spell_crit 10.33 spell_hit 17.86 spell_haste 3.98 max_mana 27950 mp5 0 mh_imbue flametongue oh_imbue flametongue mh_enchant landslide oh_enchant landslide mh_weapon mace oh_weapon axe trinket1 darkmoon_card_hurricane trinket2 fluid_death set_bonus1 t11_battlegear_4 set_bonus2 - set_bonus3 - metagem relentless_earthstorm_diamond glyph_prime1 stormstrike glyph_prime2 flametongue_weapon glyph_prime3 lava_lash glyph_major1 - glyph_major2 - glyph_major3 - armor_type_bonus 1 primary_talent enhancement elemental_weapons 2/2 focused_strikes 3/3 improved_shields 2/3 elemental_devastation 3/3 flurry 3/3 static_shock 3/3 improved_fire_nova 0/2 searing_flames 3/3 frozen_power 0/2 shamanistic_rage 1/1 unleashed_rage 2/2 improved_lava_lash 2/2 maelstrom_weapon 3/3 convection 0/2 concussion 2/3 call_of_flame 2/2 reverberation 0/2 elemental_precision 3/3 elemental_focus 0/1 elemental_oath 0/2 lava_flows 0/3 storm_earth_and_fire 0/3 elemental_mastery 0/1 feedback 0/3 lava_surge 0/2 Granted I don't play a shaman at all let alone an enhancement shaman so have no bearing on how needed/useful/situational Ancestral Swiftness is. However taking both points from it and placing them into 3/3 Improved Shields and 1/2 Improved Fire Nova also results in a further ~100dps increase. Talent Calculator - World of Warcraft DPS Report: EnhSim version 2.3.0
................................................................................
MH:
miss 738094 6.47%
dodge 0 0.00%
glancing 2737736 24.00%
hit 3528687 30.94%
crit 4400829 38.59%
average ap 15675.42
clip 0 0.00%
MH Flametongue:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 8479720 75.67%
crit 2726989 24.33%
cooldown 1330600 10.61%
average sp 13701.67
MH Storsmtrike:
miss 0 0.00%
dodge 0 0.00%
hit 1095457 58.58%
crit 774600 41.42%
average ap 15629.42
MH Unleashed Weapon Flametongue:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 834120 75.66%
crit 268293 24.34%
average sp 13714.04
OH:
miss 653666 6.48%
dodge 0 0.00%
glancing 2423047 24.01%
hit 3122759 30.95%
crit 3890747 38.56%
average ap 15671.66
clip 0 0.00%
OH Flametongue:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 7340114 75.73%
crit 2352954 24.27%
cooldown 3261522 25.18%
average sp 13700.57
OH Stormstrike:
miss 0 0.00%
dodge 0 0.00%
hit 1094252 58.51%
crit 775805 41.49%
average ap 15660.53
OH Unleashed Weapon Flametongue:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 834446 75.69%
crit 267967 24.31%
average sp 13714.04
Earth Shock:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 553748 40.64%
crit 808860 59.36%
average sp 13682.97
Flame Shock:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 718307 75.73%
crit 230174 24.27%
average sp 13720.15
dots hit 4424578 75.67%
dots crit 1422979 24.33%
average dot sp 13751.69
Lava Lash:
miss 0 0.00%
dodge 0 0.00%
hit 964546 58.53%
crit 683434 41.47%
average ap 15640.39
Lightning Bolt:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 583975 31.10%
crit 1293735 68.90%
average sp 13715.79
Lightning Shield:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 988655 40.76%
crit 1436970 59.24%
average sp 13709.30
Spirit Wolves:
miss 0 0.00%
dodge 0 0.00%
glancing 1710784 24.00%
hit 5203104 73.00%
crit 213640 3.00%
average ap 15983.58
Searing Totem:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 8124925 75.69%
crit 2609024 24.31%
average sp 13688.75
Searing Flames:
hit 3582668 75.70%
crit 1150000 24.30%
average sp 13678.58
Trinket1 Damage:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 787389 75.66%
crit 253337 24.34%
Maelstrom Weapon:
PPM 34.74
efficiency 90.10%
flurry uptime 78.33%
elemental devastation uptime 93.43%
UW Flametongue uptime 22.55%
mh enchant uptime 27.41%
oh enchant uptime 31.25%
stormstrike debuff uptime 98.96%
flame shock uptime 87.12%
lightning shield uptime 100.00%
searing totem uptime 99.76%
searing flame uptime 92.30%
MRPS without overregen
mana regen 0.11 0.04%
mp5 26.47 10.99%
replenishment 29.54 12.26%
unrelenting storm 0.00 0.00%
primal wisdom 184.80 76.71%
shamanistic rage 0.00 0.00%
mana potion 0.00 0.00%
misc 0.00 0.00%
DPS PPM MPS
white 2847.41 11.19% 71.65
flametongue 4211.68 16.55% 69.67
searing flames 1032.94 4.06% 15.78
stormstrike 1107.08 4.35% 6.23 48.68 22.50%
lava lash 3501.60 13.76% 5.49 21.45 9.91%
searing totem 3259.56 12.81% 1.09 7.47 3.45%
earth shock 1093.09 4.3% 4.54 79.81 36.88%
flame shock 1746.67 6.86% 3.16 52.47 24.25%
direct damage 472.24 27.04% 3.16
dot tick 1274.43 72.96% 19.49
lightning bolt 2661.37 10.46% 6.26 0.00 0.00%
lightning shield 1402.39 5.51% 0.14 0.00 0.00%
spirit wolves 404.85 1.59% 0.56 6.51 3.01%
unleashed elements 1632.02 6.41% 3.67 25.11 11.60%
MH Flametongue 816.07 50% 3.67
OH Flametongue 815.95 50% 3.67
Trinket1 547.56 2.15% 3.47
DPS 25448.23
MPS 216.40
MP2min 25968.42
MRPS 814.08
Out of mana time 0.00%
elapsed simulation time: 5000.00h
elapsed real time: 15.25s
simulation speed: 1180327x
config_version 2.3.0 simulation_time 5000 simulation_time_combatlog 300 combat_length 7 report_count 80 threads 1 combat_length_rng_factor 0.35 min_lag 230 max_lag 260 simulate_mana 1 cast_sr_on_cooldown 0 ep_precision 2 ep_base_stat ap ep_ap 200 ep_crit_rating 100 ep_hit_rating -100 ep_expertise_rating -100 ep_haste_rating 100 ep_mastery_rating 100 ep_spellpower 115 ep_dps 57 ep_mana 1200 ep_spirit 100 ep_mp5 100 ep_intellect 100 ep_agility 100 ep_strength 100 mh_auto_attack 1 oh_auto_attack 1 use_bloodlust 1 always_bloodlust_wolves 0 cast_lvb_only_if_fs_active 1 cast_fs_only_if_dots_left 1 cast_magma_only_if_ticks_left 1 cast_searing_only_if_ticks_left 1 cast_sr_only_if_mana_left 0 use_mana_potion_if_mana_left 1000 necrotic_touch 0 necrotic_touch_heroic 0 gloves_enchant - cloak_enchant - ring_proc - weapon_set_proc - rotation_priority_count 8 rotation_priority1 ST rotation_priority2 LL rotation_priority3 FS_UEF rotation_priority4 MW5_LB rotation_priority5 UE rotation_priority6 SS rotation_priority7 ES rotation_priority8 SW aoe_rotation_priority_count 0 fight_name standard_single_target miss 8.00 dodge 6.50 glancing 24.00 armor 11977 spell_miss 17.00 nature_resistance 0 fire_resistance 0 frost_resistance 0 arcane_resistance 0 shadow_resistance 0 additional_targets 0 additional_target_percent 0.0 additional_target_level 85 armor_debuff 12.0/12.0 physical_vulnerability_debuff 4.0/4.0 melee_haste_buff 10.0/10.0 crit_chance_buff 5.0/5.0 attack_power_buff_multiplier 10.0/10.0 spell_haste_buff 5.0/5.0 spell_crit_chance_debuff 5.0/5.0 spell_damage_debuff 8.0/8.0 spellpower_buff 10.0/10.0 percentage_damage_increase 3.0/3.0 stat_multiplier 5.0/5.0 agi_and_strength_buff 549/549 mana_buff 2126/2126 mana_regen_buff 326/326 replenishment 1 water_shield 0 mixology 1 flask_elixir flask_of_the_winds guardian_elixir - potion potion_of_the_tolvir food skewered_eel race tauren mh_speed 2.3 oh_speed 2.6 mh_dps 72.4 oh_dps 521.73 mh_crit 24.49 oh_crit 24.49 mh_hit 20.52 oh_hit 20.52 mh_expertise_rating 541 oh_expertise_rating 541 ap 10489 melee_haste 3.98 str 156 agi 4525 int 320 spi 244 mastery_rating 1963 spellpower 7761 spell_crit 10.33 spell_hit 17.86 spell_haste 3.98 max_mana 27950 mp5 0 mh_imbue flametongue oh_imbue flametongue mh_enchant landslide oh_enchant landslide mh_weapon mace oh_weapon axe trinket1 darkmoon_card_hurricane trinket2 fluid_death set_bonus1 t11_battlegear_4 set_bonus2 - set_bonus3 - metagem relentless_earthstorm_diamond glyph_prime1 stormstrike glyph_prime2 flametongue_weapon glyph_prime3 lava_lash glyph_major1 - glyph_major2 - glyph_major3 - armor_type_bonus 1 primary_talent enhancement elemental_weapons 2/2 focused_strikes 3/3 improved_shields 3/3 elemental_devastation 3/3 flurry 3/3 static_shock 3/3 improved_fire_nova 1/2 searing_flames 3/3 frozen_power 0/2 shamanistic_rage 1/1 unleashed_rage 2/2 improved_lava_lash 2/2 maelstrom_weapon 3/3 convection 0/2 concussion 2/3 call_of_flame 2/2 reverberation 0/2 elemental_precision 3/3 elemental_focus 0/1 elemental_oath 0/2 lava_flows 0/3 storm_earth_and_fire 0/3 elemental_mastery 0/1 feedback 0/3 lava_surge 0/2 EDIT: It should also be noted chardev is not activating the meta even though it should be with the gem setup nor will it activate with any gem setup I've attempted to try. As such agility shown on chardev is incorrectly displayed as 4525(4235 from gear, 4446 with mail spec). It should show 4547(4256 from gear, 4468 with mail spec). Therefore attack power is also being incorrectly displayed. 4446/1.05 = 4234.29; 4235*1.05 = 4446.8; 4235 agi from gear. As displayed on chardev. 4235+21 = 4256; 4256*1.05 = 4468.8; 4256 agi from gear. Factoring in meta gem. This is as far as I could go not knowing exactly how attack power is meant to be calculated. Chardev is definitely doing it wrong though it is also including the 10% from unleashed rage. This is making EnhSim double dip as 10% AP is checked in all the above config files. Yet another edit: Chardev is calculating attack power as the following; AP=Int/2 + Str-10 + Agi*2 - 10 Using OPs chardev setup with 0/2 unleashed rage. AP=320/2 + 156-10 + 4525*2 - 10 AP=160 + 146 + 9050 - 10 AP=9346 With 2/2 unleashed rage attack power is displayed as 10280. 9346*1.1 = 10280.6 Last edited by Penetier : 01/11/11 at 1:50 PM. |
|
|
|
|
01/11/11, 3:52 PM
|
#18 | ||||
|
Glass Joe
|
Profile: chardev 8
~26388 DPS Spec: 10/31/0
Priority:
Output: EnhSim version 2.3.0
................................................................................
MH:
miss 679306 7.23%
dodge 235801 2.51%
glancing 2254020 24.00%
hit 2249783 23.96%
crit 3971172 42.29%
average ap 16208.95
clip 1054288 10.09%
MH Flametongue:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 6755521 73.22%
crit 2470328 26.78%
cooldown 1022100 9.97%
average sp 13995.50
MH Storsmtrike:
miss 0 0.00%
dodge 45503 2.50%
hit 972804 53.50%
crit 800170 44.00%
average ap 16174.85
MH Unleashed Weapon Flametongue:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 806744 73.31%
crit 293768 26.69%
average sp 14003.35
OH:
miss 593239 7.22%
dodge 206272 2.51%
glancing 1972852 24.01%
hit 1966195 23.93%
crit 3477660 42.33%
average ap 16214.79
clip 948236 10.35%
OH Flametongue:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 5844813 73.23%
crit 2136526 26.77%
cooldown 2753413 25.65%
average sp 13999.08
OH Stormstrike:
miss 0 0.00%
dodge 44247 2.50%
hit 944580 53.28%
crit 784147 44.23%
average ap 16207.87
OH Unleashed Weapon Flametongue:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 806491 73.28%
crit 294021 26.72%
average sp 14003.35
Earth Shock:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 460993 38.25%
crit 744087 61.75%
average sp 13981.19
Flame Shock:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 710987 73.21%
crit 260211 26.79%
average sp 14008.31
dots hit 4337284 73.21%
dots crit 1587285 26.79%
average dot sp 14040.82
Lava Burst:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 1984 0.32%
crit 624586 99.68%
average sp 13984.67
Lava Lash:
miss 0 0.00%
dodge 41128 2.52%
hit 871414 53.45%
crit 717904 44.03%
average ap 16172.67
Lightning Bolt:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 715801 28.58%
crit 1788444 71.42%
average sp 14006.82
Lightning Shield:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 873737 38.15%
crit 1416599 61.85%
average sp 14009.28
Spirit Wolves:
miss 0 0.00%
dodge 179446 2.51%
glancing 1714910 24.01%
hit 5034940 70.49%
crit 213888 2.99%
average ap 16530.69
Searing Totem:
miss 0 0.00%
hit 7853540 73.20%
crit 2875240 26.80%
average sp 13983.62
Searing Flames:
hit 3468513 73.17%
crit 1272046 26.83%
average sp 13973.44
Maelstrom Weapon:
PPM 28.60
efficiency 98.09%
flurry uptime 82.71%
elemental devastation uptime 97.49%
UW Flametongue uptime 19.42%
mh enchant uptime 23.05%
oh enchant uptime 26.65%
stormstrike debuff uptime 98.94%
flame shock uptime 89.02%
lightning shield uptime 100.00%
searing totem uptime 99.78%
searing flame uptime 92.47%
trinket2 uptime 17.14%
MRPS without overregen
mana regen 0.00 0.00%
mp5 146.12 38.79%
replenishment 31.55 8.38%
unrelenting storm 0.00 0.00%
primal wisdom 199.03 52.83%
shamanistic rage 0.00 0.00%
mana potion 0.00 0.00%
misc 0.00 0.00%
DPS PPM MPS
white 2365.60 8.96% 58.69
flametongue 3685.11 13.96% 57.36
searing flames 1113.23 4.22% 15.80
stormstrike 1077.78 4.08% 6.06 47.34 13.43%
lava lash 3617.39 13.71% 5.43 21.22 6.02%
searing totem 3456.79 13.1% 1.09 7.47 2.12%
earth shock 1010.76 3.83% 4.02 70.59 20.02%
flame shock 1879.30 7.12% 3.24 53.73 15.24%
direct damage 511.69 27.23% 3.24
dot tick 1367.61 72.77% 19.75
lava burst 1024.87 3.88% 2.09 145.69 41.32%
lightning bolt 3707.08 14.05% 8.35 0.00 0.00%
lightning shield 1327.12 5.03% 0.14 0.00 0.00%
spirit wolves 400.54 1.52% 0.56 6.53 1.85%
unleashed elements 1723.03 6.53% 3.67 25.07 7.11%
MH Flametongue 861.47 50% 3.67
OH Flametongue 861.56 50% 3.67
DPS 26388.61
MPS 352.56
MP2min 42307.61
MRPS 923.55
Out of mana time 0.00%
elapsed simulation time: 5000.00h
elapsed real time: 29.13s
simulation speed: 617919x
### Saved by v2.3.0 of EnhSimGUI config_version 2.3.0 simulation_time 5000 simulation_time_combatlog 300 combat_length 7 report_count 80 threads 1 combat_length_rng_factor 0.35 min_lag 230 max_lag 260 simulate_mana 1 cast_sr_on_cooldown 0 ep_precision 2 ep_base_stat ap ep_ap 200 ep_crit_rating 100 ep_hit_rating -100 ep_expertise_rating -100 ep_haste_rating 100 ep_mastery_rating 100 ep_spellpower 115 ep_dps 57 ep_mana 1200 ep_spirit 100 ep_mp5 100 ep_intellect 100 ep_agility 100 ep_strength 100 mh_auto_attack 1 oh_auto_attack 1 use_bloodlust 1 always_bloodlust_wolves 0 cast_lvb_only_if_fs_active 1 cast_fs_only_if_dots_left 1 cast_magma_only_if_ticks_left 1 cast_searing_only_if_ticks_left 1 cast_sr_only_if_mana_left 0 use_mana_potion_if_mana_left 1000 necrotic_touch 0 necrotic_touch_heroic 0 gloves_enchant - cloak_enchant - ring_proc - weapon_set_proc - rotation_priority_count 13 rotation_priority1 ST rotation_priority2 LL rotation_priority3 FS_UEF rotation_priority4 MW5_LB rotation_priority5 MW4_LB rotation_priority6 UE rotation_priority7 SS rotation_priority8 SW rotation_priority9 MW3_LB rotation_priority10 LVB_UEF rotation_priority11 ES rotation_priority12 LVB rotation_priority13 MW2_LB aoe_rotation_priority_count 0 fight_name standard_single_target miss 8.00 dodge 6.50 glancing 24.00 armor 11977 spell_miss 17.00 nature_resistance 0 fire_resistance 0 frost_resistance 0 arcane_resistance 0 shadow_resistance 0 additional_targets 0 additional_target_percent 0.00 additional_target_level 85 armor_debuff 12.0/12.0 physical_vulnerability_debuff 4.0/4.0 melee_haste_buff 10.0/10.0 crit_chance_buff 5.0/5.0 attack_power_buff_multiplier 10.0/10.0 spell_haste_buff 5.0/5.0 spell_crit_chance_debuff 5.0/5.0 spell_damage_debuff 8.0/8.0 spellpower_buff 10.0/10.0 percentage_damage_increase 3.0/3.0 stat_multiplier 5.0/5.0 agi_and_strength_buff 549/549 mana_buff 2126/2126 mana_regen_buff 326/326 replenishment 1 water_shield 0 mixology 1 flask_elixir flask_of_the_winds guardian_elixir - potion potion_of_the_tolvir food skewered_eel ############################################################################### ### Everything in the section below can be replaced by information obtained ### ### from your paper doll stats or exported by the ShockAndAwe addon ### ############################################################################### race tauren mh_speed 2.3 oh_speed 2.6 mh_dps 72.4 oh_dps 521.8 mh_crit 25.74 oh_crit 25.74 mh_hit 19.78 oh_hit 19.78 mh_expertise_rating 239 oh_expertise_rating 239 ap 11092 melee_haste 3.21 str 156 agi 4799 int 320 spi 244 mastery_rating 2366 spellpower 8063 spell_crit 10.74 spell_hit 16.99 spell_haste 3.21 max_mana 27950 mp5 1171 mh_imbue flametongue oh_imbue flametongue mh_enchant landslide oh_enchant landslide mh_weapon mace oh_weapon axe trinket1 fluid_death trinket2 essence_of_the_cyclone_heroic set_bonus1 t11_battlegear_4 set_bonus2 - set_bonus3 - metagem - glyph_prime1 stormstrike glyph_prime2 flametongue_weapon glyph_prime3 lava_lash glyph_major1 - glyph_major2 - glyph_major3 - armor_type_bonus 1 primary_talent enhancement elemental_weapons 2/2 focused_strikes 3/3 improved_shields 2/3 elemental_devastation 3/3 flurry 3/3 static_shock 3/3 improved_fire_nova 0/2 searing_flames 3/3 frozen_power 0/2 shamanistic_rage 1/1 unleashed_rage 2/2 improved_lava_lash 2/2 maelstrom_weapon 3/3 convection 0/2 concussion 2/3 call_of_flame 2/2 reverberation 0/2 elemental_precision 3/3 elemental_focus 0/1 elemental_oath 0/2 lava_flows 0/3 storm_earth_and_fire 0/3 elemental_mastery 0/1 feedback 0/3 lava_surge 0/2 |
||||
|
|
|
|
01/11/11, 6:50 PM
|
#20 | |||
|
Piston Honda
|
After this point, I will refrain from discussing SR publicly. I'd be happy to discuss it privately with anyone though. |
|||
|
|
|
|
01/11/11, 7:39 PM
|
#21 | |
|
Glass Joe
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
01/12/11, 2:35 AM
|
#22 |
|
Piston Honda
|
I'd like to add a small contribution to the BiS thread by making it a little easier to find EnhSim values and see if a particular item is an upgrade over the existing one.
Item Comparison 4.0.3c  The spreadsheet is very easy to use. 1. Input your current EnhSim data on the right most white column. 2. Manipulate the options for matching armor pieces and talent points in the lower right hand corner. 3. Input the current item that you are using on the left most white column. 4. Input the new item that you are investigating on the middle column. The blue fields are areas that should not be messed with (unless I made a mistake, then feel free to point it out so I can correct it). The new EnhSim values can be off by values of 0.01% and 1, depending on how your in game values are currently being rounded by the character sheet UI. This should not throw off your data by an appreciable amount, and short of an exhaustive effort of summing up the stat values of all of your current items, there is no way to 'fix' this issue. If you have any questions, let me know! Update 4.0.3c:
Update 4.0.3b:
Last edited by Hothgor : 01/13/11 at 2:08 AM. |
|
|
|
|
01/12/11, 6:37 AM
|
#23 | |
|
Glass Joe
|
For the time being, my stance on talents will be if you can prove that taking a certain talent (as is the case with Elemental Precision) will have an impact on gear, gems, reforges etc. I'll update the OP accordingly, but otherwise all posts must include Shamanistic Rage and Ancestral Swiftness. The only place where it will have a noticeable impact on anything is Elemental Precision - currently, if your weapon has spirit, it has a very large effect on all of your gear. Without a spirit weapon, it's a simple gem swap. 20 spirit from your chest enchant is easy to work around (with 3/3) by switching a Sensei's to a Rigid or vice versa. Due to this, I'll update the OP with a 3/3 Elemental Precision setup as soon as I have time. |
|
|
|
|
|
01/12/11, 8:19 AM
|
#24 | |
|
DFTBA
|
|
|
|
|
|
01/12/11, 8:44 AM
|
#25 | |
|
Piston Honda
|
|
|
|
|
|
 |
 |
|
|||||||
| Thread Tools | |
|
|
Similar Threads
|
||||
| Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
| [Enhancement] BiS gear and set-up discussion (3.3 and onward) | rava | Shamans | 171 | 10/14/10 10:20 AM |
«
Shaman: Simple Questions thread reboot -- new kinder gentler rule-7-free zone
|
Mists of Pandaria Shaman bugs
»
