Elitist Jerks
Register
Blogs
Forums


Go Back   Elitist Jerks » Shamans

Closed Thread
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
Old 05/12/08, 1:27 PM   #1826
Mox
Piston Honda
 
Human Paladin
 
Azjol-Nerub (EU)
Originally Posted by Mmootimus View Post
Has there ever been a definitive blue answer on the legality of AHK for spell-spamming, or are so many people using it now anyway that the point has become moot?

I dug around a bit, and this blue post makes it reasonably clear Blizz disapprove. However I have never heard of them taking any action, and keyboards can of course do the same thing.
I ticketed a GM afew days ago explicitly asking whether "Repetition of a key" is acceptable, whether it be by a G15 keyboard or AHK. The GM said as long as you are physically sat pressing the keys that were being repeated then there was no problem and it was just the same as a auto-fire function. He actually said he wasn't aware that a G15 keyboard could do it and was going to go out and buy one for his fire mage :P

Blizzard class botting as automated character control with no human interaction, which is where the "you need to be at the keyboard pressing the keys" comes from.

Offline
Old 05/12/08, 1:36 PM   #1827
GoG
Purple Idiot
 
Tauren Shaman
 
Maelstrom
Originally Posted by Chaostheoryx View Post
I want to point out for everyone here that just one person using the LagInfo addon can increase your raid DPS anywhere between 2 and 5%. I wouldn't think of doing Brutallus without having this addon to monitor caster performance in your raid. All the casters in my guild were at 160 - 240ms intervals before using this mod. Now every one of them is 0 - 50ms. Our mages are finally starting to catch up to me... Also, client-server latency is NOT a significant factor or valid excuse. No one should be in the triple digits.

So give that addon a try. Gain new insight into how yourself and your fellow casters are doing and perhaps find a free 2-5% DPS gain for your raids.
I've installed it and haven't figured out how to make it show anymore than just my latency. /laginfo does nothing and I didnt see any obvious documentation associated with the mod.


Offline
Old 05/12/08, 2:11 PM   #1828
Clown_Cracker
Glass Joe
 
Tauren Shaman
 
Dunemaul
Sorry to change the topic but I have a gear question:

Lately I have been debating all the haste I have been using. As it currently stands I have 182 haste, with 1078 damage (with 23.23% to crit with all spells). I do not have access to the 4piece t6 (I will not for awhile, although I do have the 2piece t6). I was thinking if I switched haste gems to crit gems, my dps would increase since I could use the 3/1 rotation. Personally in raids I need to chain chug mana pots to stay efficient (otherwise I go oom). So I could get 0 haste, 30.6% to crit with all spells, and 1099 damage. So I wanted some other perspectives on the situation.

Offline
Old 05/12/08, 2:16 PM   #1829
Chaostheoryx
Von Kaiser
 
Orc Shaman
 
Daggerspine
Originally Posted by GoG View Post
I've installed it and haven't figured out how to make it show anymore than just my latency. /laginfo does nothing and I didnt see any obvious documentation associated with the mod.
When you're in a party or raid, mouse over the text display and it displays a tooltip. This will show everyone's measurement once it has collected data for them (which requires at least two consecutive casts).

Offline
Old 05/12/08, 2:58 PM   #1830
Zene
Von Kaiser
 
Troll Druid
 
Skullcrusher
Originally Posted by Chaostheoryx View Post
I want to point out for everyone here that just one person using the LagInfo addon can increase your raid DPS anywhere between 2 and 5%. I wouldn't think of doing Brutallus without having this addon to monitor caster performance in your raid. All the casters in my guild were at 160 - 240ms intervals before using this mod. Now every one of them is 0 - 50ms. Our mages are finally starting to catch up to me... Also, client-server latency is NOT a significant factor or valid excuse. No one should be in the triple digits.

So give that addon a try. Gain new insight into how yourself and your fellow casters are doing and perhaps find a free 2-5% DPS gain for your raids.
So what would be the steps? Find the casters who are over 100 ms using LagInfo in the raid? Then get them to use something like AHK? Or what else can you suggest to them, as I know I have a lot of non-tech-savvy people I raid with?

Offline
Old 05/12/08, 3:07 PM   #1831
Chaostheoryx
Von Kaiser
 
Orc Shaman
 
Daggerspine
The 'old fashioned way' I suppose: Quartz + spam their buttons more.

But I've talked total computer neophytes through installing AHK and then making the script for them to paste in. And then there are the Logitech keyboards.

Last edited by Chaostheoryx : 05/12/08 at 3:36 PM.

Offline
Old 05/12/08, 3:37 PM   #1832
Zene
Von Kaiser
 
Troll Druid
 
Skullcrusher
Originally Posted by Chaostheoryx View Post
The 'old fashioned way' I suppose: Quartz + spam their buttons more.

So, stupid question then =/ Quartz back in the day was used in conjunction with the little red part of the casting bar and /stopcasting macro's. What does it exactly do for you now? Or how are you supposed to use it now?

Offline
Old 05/12/08, 3:51 PM   #1833
Kaideq
Von Kaiser
 
Troll Shaman
 
Twilight's Hammer (EU)
The difference between mashing the key and using something like AHK/G15 is minimal if even existant at all with the queue system if you're using 1 spell, if you're at 160/240 you're just not mashing the key.

Offline
Old 05/12/08, 4:07 PM   #1834
Daidalos
Great Tiger
 
Tauren Shaman
 
Korgath
Originally Posted by Clown_Cracker View Post
Sorry to change the topic but I have a gear question:

Lately I have been debating all the haste I have been using. As it currently stands I have 182 haste, with 1078 damage (with 23.23% to crit with all spells). I do not have access to the 4piece t6 (I will not for awhile, although I do have the 2piece t6). I was thinking if I switched haste gems to crit gems, my dps would increase since I could use the 3/1 rotation. Personally in raids I need to chain chug mana pots to stay efficient (otherwise I go oom). So I could get 0 haste, 30.6% to crit with all spells, and 1099 damage. So I wanted some other perspectives on the situation.
Run each setup and compare the dps output and time till OOM


Offline
Old 05/12/08, 4:30 PM   #1835
Mirranda
Von Kaiser
 
Mirranda's Avatar
 
Night Elf Hunter
 
Tichondrius
Originally Posted by Clown_Cracker View Post
Sorry to change the topic but I have a gear question:

Lately I have been debating all the haste I have been using. As it currently stands I have 182 haste, with 1078 damage (with 23.23% to crit with all spells). I do not have access to the 4piece t6 (I will not for awhile, although I do have the 2piece t6). I was thinking if I switched haste gems to crit gems, my dps would increase since I could use the 3/1 rotation. Personally in raids I need to chain chug mana pots to stay efficient (otherwise I go oom). So I could get 0 haste, 30.6% to crit with all spells, and 1099 damage. So I wanted some other perspectives on the situation.
182 Haste seems kind of high to be using a 3:1 rotation also. But definitely try what the poster above me said before you go spend the gold to regem. Another thing is whether or not you consistently get a shadow priest. A lot of people don't believe me when I tell them I run OOM without one but I can't spend more than 2000 mana in a 6 minute fight with one, but it makes that big of a difference.

Pretend I typed something witty.

Offline
Old 05/12/08, 4:41 PM   #1836
GoG
Purple Idiot
 
Tauren Shaman
 
Maelstrom
Originally Posted by Kaideq View Post
The difference between mashing the key and using something like AHK/G15 is minimal if even existant at all with the queue system if you're using 1 spell, if you're at 160/240 you're just not mashing the key.
Have you tested that statement? I have, and I notice a big difference. I suppose I could be mashing even faster when beating up on dr boom. but I think I would break my keyboard. In fact, I even noticed a difference between sending my lbolt command every millisecond vs. every 50 milliseconds. I tried asking before how the implementation of the queue system could make a difference and I didn't quite understand chaos's answer, so I decided to use empirical testing and I was surprised.


Offline
Old 05/12/08, 6:26 PM   #1837
Chaostheoryx
Von Kaiser
 
Orc Shaman
 
Daggerspine
Originally Posted by Zene View Post
So, stupid question then =/ Quartz back in the day was used in conjunction with the little red part of the casting bar and /stopcasting macro's. What does it exactly do for you now? Or how are you supposed to use it now?
Quartz isn't really necessary, it's just to emphasize to people that they need to start spamming (or macro) before cast completion. Otherwise it does nothing. Edit: Oh, I do like the GCD 'spark bar' though.

Last edited by Chaostheoryx : 05/12/08 at 6:45 PM.

Offline
Old 05/12/08, 6:50 PM   #1838
Chaostheoryx
Von Kaiser
 
Orc Shaman
 
Daggerspine
Originally Posted by GoG View Post
I tried asking before how the implementation of the queue system could make a difference and I didn't quite understand chaos's answer, so I decided to use empirical testing and I was surprised.
I don't know that there is a spell queue mechanism. The following contributes to my skepticism:
"The designers aren't planning on adding a spell queue, since that destroys the immediate response between input and action." -Slouken, on upcoming 2.3 changes

Offline
Old 05/12/08, 10:26 PM   #1839
Binkenstein
mumbo-jumbo-theorycrafter
 
Binkenstein's Avatar
 
Draenei Shaman
 
Khaz'goroth
Which is why I refer to it as the "spell queue" because it's not really one, but it kinda works that way.

Following that link, I saw this:
The current thought is also that we won't be sending casts to the server during the global cooldown, both to reduce bandwidth (and flood disconnections) and to lessen the incentive to spam cast.
If this is correct, that may be part of the reason why we see odd behaviour around CL use.


New Zealand Offline
Old 05/13/08, 2:03 AM   #1840
tufy
Don Flamenco
 
tufy's Avatar
 
Nathaira
Draenei Shaman
 
No WoW Account (EU)
Originally Posted by Clown_Cracker View Post
Sorry to change the topic but I have a gear question:

Lately I have been debating all the haste I have been using. As it currently stands I have 182 haste, with 1078 damage (with 23.23% to crit with all spells). I do not have access to the 4piece t6 (I will not for awhile, although I do have the 2piece t6). I was thinking if I switched haste gems to crit gems, my dps would increase since I could use the 3/1 rotation. Personally in raids I need to chain chug mana pots to stay efficient (otherwise I go oom). So I could get 0 haste, 30.6% to crit with all spells, and 1099 damage. So I wanted some other perspectives on the situation.
I don't know your exact stats, so these are estimates based on my own gear with your crit, damage and haste put in. Also, I assumed the use of Lightning Capacitor, as I don't know what trinkets you have.

LB spam with haste:
dps:1720
oom in: 127 seconds

LB spam with crit:
dps: 1629
oom in: 159 seconds

CL-4LB with haste:
dps: 1,816
oom in: 79 seconds

CL-4LB with crit:
dps: 1721
oom in: 95

It's quite obvious that crit gives you more damage overall, however, that is only true if you can spend your whole mana pool. Considering LB spam with haste is as powerful as CL-4LB rotation with crit and lasts longer as well, it should be considered the superior of the two.

In other words: gogo, haste.

Creativity requires the courage to let go of certainties.

Slovenia Offline
Old 05/13/08, 2:47 AM   #1841
Mirranda
Von Kaiser
 
Mirranda's Avatar
 
Night Elf Hunter
 
Tichondrius
Originally Posted by tufy View Post
I don't know your exact stats, so these are estimates based on my own gear with your crit, damage and haste put in. Also, I assumed the use of Lightning Capacitor, as I don't know what trinkets you have.

LB spam with haste:
dps:1720
oom in: 127 seconds

LB spam with crit:
dps: 1629
oom in: 159 seconds

CL-4LB with haste:
dps: 1,816
oom in: 79 seconds

CL-4LB with crit:
dps: 1721
oom in: 95

It's quite obvious that crit gives you more damage overall, however, that is only true if you can spend your whole mana pool. Considering LB spam with haste is as powerful as CL-4LB rotation with crit and lasts longer as well, it should be considered the superior of the two.

In other words: gogo, haste.
Correction to the bold part, if you're doing all crit with CL, you should be doing a 3:1 rotation for optimal DPS, unless I'm misunderstanding what you're saying there.

Pretend I typed something witty.

Offline
Old 05/13/08, 3:50 AM   #1842
tufy
Don Flamenco
 
tufy's Avatar
 
Nathaira
Draenei Shaman
 
No WoW Account (EU)
Originally Posted by Mirranda View Post
Correction to the bold part, if you're doing all crit with CL, you should be doing a 3:1 rotation for optimal DPS, unless I'm misunderstanding what you're saying there.
You're right, I'm sorry, I just plugged in the numbers with brain asleep :p

CL-3LB:
dps: 1742
oom in: 86 seconds

Creativity requires the courage to let go of certainties.

Slovenia Offline
Old 05/13/08, 9:47 AM   #1843
Buanna
Piston Honda
 
Troll Shaman
 
Hellscream
Are you remembering to account for the dead time in a 3-1 rotation? It's impossible to be casting the entire time. You can't queue a spell on cooldown. There's also some nonsense with lightning overload perhaps resetting the cooldown, but I don't remember exactly how that went.


Offline
Old 05/13/08, 12:12 PM   #1844
Niley
Glass Joe
 
Niley's Avatar
 
Draenei Shaman
 
Stormreaver
after all this, I decided to jump the bandwagon and try going haste way, right now I'm sitting at 300 haste, 1130ish damage and 26% crit. When I had 1200 damage and 120 haste, I did around 1950 dps on brut, tonight Ill test my new set up.
I'm really curious to see the results.

Offline
Old 05/13/08, 4:31 PM   #1845
Mirranda
Von Kaiser
 
Mirranda's Avatar
 
Night Elf Hunter
 
Tichondrius
Originally Posted by Buanna View Post
Are you remembering to account for the dead time in a 3-1 rotation? It's impossible to be casting the entire time. You can't queue a spell on cooldown. There's also some nonsense with lightning overload perhaps resetting the cooldown, but I don't remember exactly how that went.
The LO resetting CD was a speculation and testing has shown to the contrary.

Pretend I typed something witty.

Offline
Old 05/13/08, 4:40 PM   #1846
Shaftoe
Glass Joe
 
Shaftoe's Avatar
 
Orc Death Knight
 
Duskwood
Originally Posted by Niley View Post
after all this, I decided to jump the bandwagon and try going haste way, right now I'm sitting at 300 haste, 1130ish damage and 26% crit. When I had 1200 damage and 120 haste, I did around 1950 dps on brut, tonight Ill test my new set up.
I'm really curious to see the results.
Niley could you post the wws of that brut attempt/kill? I like to look and see how many drums/blood lusts/destro pots/BM Hunters shamans have when they start getting close to 2k in their wws's. We have not had very many runs to enrage in 2 nights of attempts (3 total I believe) so I've not had a chance to really gauge the impact of a full consumable/cool down run and crave input.

No more gimped eh?

Offline
Old 05/13/08, 4:48 PM   #1847
tufy
Don Flamenco
 
tufy's Avatar
 
Nathaira
Draenei Shaman
 
No WoW Account (EU)
Originally Posted by Buanna View Post
Are you remembering to account for the dead time in a 3-1 rotation? It's impossible to be casting the entire time. You can't queue a spell on cooldown. There's also some nonsense with lightning overload perhaps resetting the cooldown, but I don't remember exactly how that went.
If you have no haste, there is no dead time in 3-1. The delay has been calculated, of course, as a comparison with 4-1 rotation for low haste values.

Here's a sample based on my gear:

http://i223.photobucket.com/albums/d...spreadnath.jpg

Note: some figures like crit sum and haste sum will appear wrong. That's because I recently swapped gems from crit to haste and haven't come around to fixing the charts yet, so I just added "-40" value to crit and "+40" to haste totals.

Creativity requires the courage to let go of certainties.

Slovenia Offline
Old 05/13/08, 4:51 PM   #1848
Niley
Glass Joe
 
Niley's Avatar
 
Draenei Shaman
 
Stormreaver
Originally Posted by Shaftoe View Post
Niley could you post the wws of that brut attempt/kill? I like to look and see how many drums/blood lusts/destro pots/BM Hunters shamans have when they start getting close to 2k in their wws's. We have not had very many runs to enrage in 2 nights of attempts (3 total I believe) so I've not had a chance to really gauge the impact of a full consumable/cool down run and crave input.

No more gimped eh?
Sure, here You go, just pick Brut from the drop down.
Wow Web Stats
and yeah, gimped is done for

Offline
Old 05/13/08, 6:24 PM   #1849
kasouti
Von Kaiser
 
Troll Shaman
 
Archimonde
Originally Posted by Shaftoe View Post
Niley could you post the wws of that brut attempt/kill? I like to look and see how many drums/blood lusts/destro pots/BM Hunters shamans have when they start getting close to 2k in their wws's. We have not had very many runs to enrage in 2 nights of attempts (3 total I believe) so I've not had a chance to really gauge the impact of a full consumable/cool down run and crave input.

No more gimped eh?
I don't really post much in this thread, but I did manage a 2300 wws with 2 lusts and 2 people rotating drums. Also had a ret pally, 2 enhance shaman, and a moonkin. Killed him about 4 seconds prior to the enrage. If you wanted to view it.

Wow Web Stats

Also Niley your WWS seems to error out for me at least.

Offline
Old 05/14/08, 1:19 AM   #1850
Mirranda
Von Kaiser
 
Mirranda's Avatar
 
Night Elf Hunter
 
Tichondrius
Originally Posted by kasouti View Post
I don't really post much in this thread, but I did manage a 2300 wws with 2 lusts and 2 people rotating drums. Also had a ret pally, 2 enhance shaman, and a moonkin. Killed him about 4 seconds prior to the enrage. If you wanted to view it.

Wow Web Stats

Also Niley your WWS seems to error out for me at least.
Wow @ your DPS. I really can't figure out how that works @_@

Judging by your armory, I've got more damage, more haste, and roughly the same crit, usually have 3 sets of drums vs your 2, and also get 2 Bloodlusts, and yet I sit usually at about 1950-1980.

Does a moonkin make that large of a difference?

At a second glance, I don't know if we've had an enhancement shaman the last few weeks, that's probably it, seeing as you had 2.

Pretend I typed something witty.

Offline
Closed Thread

Go Back   Elitist Jerks » Shamans

Thread Tools

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Stop the Fizzle Demi9OD User Interface and AddOns 44 04/15/07 12:19 PM
Stop Mercutius The Dung Heap 2 01/15/07 7:48 PM
Check this cool WOW SHOP Antiyou The Dung Heap 3 09/09/06 3:47 PM
Stop. LodeRunner Public Discussion 13 06/21/05 2:18 PM