Enhancement Glyphs a numeric comparison - Page 12

Prinnybomb · 07/01/09, 2:02 PM

I have a question. I'm sure its been noted somewhere but I am unable to find it.

For feral spirits, and the glyph.

Is this ability similar to earthshield, for example, when you proc a spell power trinket and refresh it, it will make your ES stay at that level of spell power.

So do I want to pop everything, or wait for a trinket proc before popping my dogs, or do they flucuate with my trinkets and attack power while they are up?

Also, do they scale with only our attack power, no haste, armor pen, etc...?

Sorry if this has been ask before.

SentinelBorg · 07/01/09, 6:56 PM

Originally Posted by Prinnybomb

For feral spirits, and the glyph.

Is this ability similar to earthshield, for example, when you proc a spell power trinket and refresh it, it will make your ES stay at that level of spell power.

So do I want to pop everything, or wait for a trinket proc before popping my dogs, or do they flucuate with my trinkets and attack power while they are up?

Also, do they scale with only our attack power, no haste, armor pen, etc...?

Their AP fluctuates with yours while they are up. As far as I know, they only scale with our AP and stamina, but this will change with 3.2.

Levva · 07/27/09, 11:22 AM

Originally Posted by SentinelBorg

Their AP fluctuates with yours while they are up. As far as I know, they only scale with our AP and stamina, but this will change with 3.2.

If you check the EnhSim thread you will find my post from a few months back where I did a lot of testing and discovered that they benefit from our strength getting 2 AP from 1 STR (guess what Blizz forgot to change during patch 3.0 beta) as well as any AP buffs when they are called. They have a fixed speed but benefit from haste buffs applied to them directly or via auras eg: Bloodlust/Heroism Windfury totem.

If you have ShockAndAwe installed it activates your pet tab so you can see your wolves stats when you summon them.

Rouncer · 08/29/09, 12:44 PM

Originally Posted by Levva

If you check the EnhSim thread you will find my post from a few months back where I did a lot of testing and discovered that they benefit from our strength getting 2 AP from 1 STR (guess what Blizz forgot to change during patch 3.0 beta) as well as any AP buffs when they are called. They have a fixed speed but benefit from haste buffs applied to them directly or via auras eg: Bloodlust/Heroism Windfury totem.

If you have ShockAndAwe installed it activates your pet tab so you can see your wolves stats when you summon them.

That's actually wrong now. They scale from AP not from Strength. Originally they scaled from strength but that was changed in a subsequent patch. They get basically 31% of our AP and Stamina, 61% with the glyph.

Script to turn on pet tab - /run if not oldHasPetUI then oldHasPetUI = HasPetUI; HasPetUI = function() return true, false; end end PetTab_Update() ToggleCharacter("PetPaperDollFrame")

Some quick testing.

Testing Condition	My AP	Feral Spirits AP
Naked	464	925
AP Trinket	654	1040
Agi Scroll	489	940
Raiding Gear	4570	3429
Chest Piece only	880	1178

This is with the glyph in place and it is clear they are getting 61% of my AP and that the AP values change from moment to moment. In my full raiding gear I only have 143 strength so there is no way that they can be scaling off of that and my Agility is only 998 so they also aren't scaling off of that either.

Levva · 09/24/09, 1:10 PM

My previous testing showed they got 31% of shaman AP + 2 * his STR and base 206.17 dps. Do you reckon the STR component was dropped?

Rouncer · 09/24/09, 1:55 PM

Originally Posted by Levva

My previous testing showed they got 31% of shaman AP + 2 * his STR and base 206.17 dps. Do you reckon the STR component was dropped?

It was awhile back. They changed it to AP instead of Strength.

passislisk · 09/25/09, 2:11 PM

With the (very likely) new change to Enh shaman's rotations to include FS not just earthshock does that change the value of the earth shock glyph enough to provide the next glyph (not even sure what it is anymore) to pull ahead?

Note: Assuming feral spirits and stormstrike are still the essentially undisputed best two major glyphs.

Mogadee · 09/25/09, 4:41 PM

There has been some discussion about the 4pc t9 set and the viability of the Lightning Shield glyph. The feral Spirit glyph really on shines if wolves are popped every cd regardless of the situation. I know I like to save my wolves for hero/bl to get that added bonus. I am usually the one to pop hero in our raids and talk to rl about when he wants hero so i can plan accordingly on my wolves.

If you have 4pc t9, SS, lightning shield, and flame shock glyphs would very good choices. I am currently using SS, feral spirits, and either WF or FS glyphs. I am still testing FS glyph viability with my gear.

Levva · 09/25/09, 5:47 PM

Originally Posted by Rouncer

It was awhile back. They changed it to AP instead of Strength.

Sorry Rouncer just rechecked it now. I have 468 AP naked. 61% of that (with glyph is 285) looking at pet tab Wolves say 927 AP and their tooltip says 642+285. Looking at their strength they have 331 Str and the tooltip when they were NOT summoned said -20. So my original findings of 2*str -20 + .61% AP stands.

ie: 2*331 -20 + .61*468 = 642 + 285 (exactly what wolves tooltip says).

ShockAndAwe auto turns on the pet tab so anyone with ShockAndAwe installed can check this for themselves.

Formulae is therefore confirmed as 2x(dogs STR) - 20 + (.31+.3 if FS glyph)*shaman AP. Given you thought this was wrong it would be useful to know what the Sim is coded as.

Rouncer · 09/26/09, 11:45 AM

Originally Posted by Levva

Sorry Rouncer just rechecked it now. I have 468 AP naked. 61% of that (with glyph is 285) looking at pet tab Wolves say 927 AP and their tooltip says 642+285. Looking at their strength they have 331 Str and the tooltip when they were NOT summoned said -20. So my original findings of 2*str -20 + .61% AP stands.

ie: 2*331 -20 + .61*468 = 642 + 285 (exactly what wolves tooltip says).

ShockAndAwe auto turns on the pet tab so anyone with ShockAndAwe installed can check this for themselves.

Formulae is therefore confirmed as 2x(dogs STR) - 20 + (.31+.3 if FS glyph)*shaman AP. Given you thought this was wrong it would be useful to know what the Sim is coded as.

They get 2x their strength but they don't get any of our strength anymore. That was what I thought you were talking about, they changed the wolves to scale off our AP not off our strength.

You owe me 10g by the way, for making me actually go and buy a pair of strength pants to confirm this again. They had 331 strength without me wearing the pants and they had exactly 331 strength when I am wearing the pants. So their strength is unaffected by our strength and their Power only scales based on our AP.

Since I'm playing I figured it would be interesting to see what would happen if I buffed a wolf with a Scroll of Strength (30 strength). The buffed wolf was definitely hitting harder then the other wolf and the pet tab showed a gain of 60 AP.

Levva · 09/26/09, 11:12 PM

Originally Posted by Rouncer

They get 2x their strength but they don't get any of our strength anymore. That was what I thought you were talking about, they changed the wolves to scale off our AP not off our strength.

You owe me 10g by the way, for making me actually go and buy a pair of strength pants to confirm this again. They had 331 strength without me wearing the pants and they had exactly 331 strength when I am wearing the pants. So their strength is unaffected by our strength and their Power only scales based on our AP.

Since I'm playing I figured it would be interesting to see what would happen if I buffed a wolf with a Scroll of Strength (30 strength). The buffed wolf was definitely hitting harder then the other wolf and the pet tab showed a gain of 60 AP.

Will take me a bit of time to pay you back. I'll need to create a lvl 1 on Mal'Ganis first do you recommend a Orc, Troll or Tauren?

Just us getting our wires crossed I did not mean wolves got AP from OUR strength only their strength. Cheaper test would of course have been drop SoE totem or use a scroll of Strength on yourself vs pet even a lvl 1 scroll.

Hmm now I think of it I'm not so sure I really owe you actually. A lvl 1 scroll is NOT 10g if it is on your server then I'm off to level inscription on Mal'Ganis

On a side note - do you think casual readers will now think EJ forums is recommending buffing their wolves with Scroll of Strength VIII once summoned to get extra 60AP on that one wolf?

Vespasian · 09/27/09, 12:59 AM

Originally Posted by Levva

On a side note - do you think casual readers will now think EJ forums is recommending buffing their wolves with Scroll of Strength VIII once summoned to get extra 60AP on that one wolf?

I will be sure to add this to the Bis page

hozzer · 09/27/09, 3:42 AM

On players, this scroll does not stack with SoE. Is it different for wolves?

Puza · 09/27/09, 6:57 AM

Has the math been done to quantify the benefit of Glyph of Flameshock in comparison to;

1) [Glyph of Windfury Weapon]
2) [Glyph of Stormstrike]
3) [Glyph of Feral Spirit]

While the general consensus seemes to be replace Windfury, I would be interested to find out the extent of the benefit, and if this is in fact a valid reccomendation.

maelfus · 09/27/09, 7:20 AM

Just get your paladins to rebuff might and kings on warriors whenever you pop your spirit wolves.

Spaceinvader · 10/01/09, 1:41 PM

Originally Posted by Levva

Formulae is therefore confirmed as 2x(dogs STR) - 20 + (.31+.3 if FS glyph)*shaman AP. Given you thought this was wrong it would be useful to know what the Sim is coded as.

Even though you guys ended up being on the same page, just thought I would mentioned that I took a look at the EnhSim code and SW AP is calculated properly according to your formula. The wolves have their own independent stats (e.g. STR, haste) that are properly buffed by raid-wide buffs from your config file (e.g. totems, but not blessings/shouts). So all looks kosher.

speirling82 · 10/15/09, 3:44 PM

Saw the posted numbers about few of the glyphs, but still a few I was wondering about. Mainly lighting bolt, with 4% more damage from the lighting bolt. I know my shaman ill stack mealstorm pretty fast. So would the lb glyphs be worth the slot. And would the 200 haste Lb ele totem matter into that? thanks for any feed back on this

Levva · 10/16/09, 7:17 AM

In the Rawr Enhance thread [Enhancement] Rawr.Enhance thread I posted initial results from Rawr.Enhance with FlameShock glyph support could those interested in the maths check the validity of the calculations please.

Kyuuzo · 11/06/09, 4:41 AM

Trying buffing your wolves, isn't neither a bad idea nor a good one to me. The thing is that it might end up being too much of a fuss, or even too lifeconsuming, especially if you raid serious bosses(not that there any atm) which you have to pay attention all the time, and trying to buff your wolfs at that times wouldn't be the best thing. Enhancement spec is rly cool to play, tho sometimes tiring. But in general, it needs to much effort, and a great amount of time to deal with, i kudo all of you guys that deal with numeric comparison and stuff, you rly help community, such guys like myself would never be able to do such stuff. Tho i most of the times get confused ^_^