Elitist Jerks
Register
Blogs
Forums


Go Back   Elitist Jerks » Class Mechanics » Shamans

Closed Thread
 
LinkBack Thread Tools
Old 03/06/09, 4:05 AM   #526
Curtis
Von Kaiser
 
Curtis's Avatar
 
Dwarf Hunter
 
Vol'jin (EU)
Originally Posted by Mordekhuul View Post
Quick question - feel free to PM answers rather than post if it isn't general enough to be interesting to the (mostly raiding) population here.

I play a lot more than my wife, lately, and given her lack of raiding, I'm looking to aquire one or more upgrades for her. I have cash, thanks to Jewelcrafting.

I was thinking [Titansteel Guardian] as it is clearly better than what she has, a little, but any suggestion for pre-raid gear or a link to suggestions would be appreciated.

Her armory: The World of Warcraft Armory.
Hello,

Yes it is. But there are sooooo much upgrades to be done. In such a case i would rather make some hero/10 men and then spend some gold to fill the last spots.

Anyway there are some ideas :
*craft mace
*JC craft blue ring (hit/crit/sp/socket)
*JC craft epic ring (crit/sp/socket)
*tailoring craft back (crit/haste/sp)
*badge belt cloth then offhand as soon as she has the badges
*thaddius gloves (BoE)

Offline
Old 03/06/09, 6:31 AM   #527
Kaideq
Von Kaiser
 
Troll Shaman
 
Twilight's Hammer (EU)
Mmootimus,

I had some spare time while cleaning up around here and put my g15 to use. I specced out of Lightning overload and Elemental Oath to avoid having to remove the buffs and filter the Lightning overload procs.
It is likely not enough for a quality empirical conclusion, but 1500+ bolts results are as follows;

Lowest hit 2930
Spell damage on gear: 2275
783 + (2275*0.814*1,09) = 2801,5165

These results support your previous statement on the effect of the totem of hex/Lb Glyph.

Offline
Old 03/06/09, 7:59 AM   #528
bkoehler
Banned
 
Orc Shaman
 
Shattered Halls
wanton spellcaster vs bene gauntlets

i have been rearranging gear and re-gemming trying to get the ideal setup.

i have been messign with swtichign the [Valorous Earthshatter Gloves] with the [Benefactor's Gauntlets] as most peope have been doing.

i have also been trying using the [Valorous Earthshatter Gloves] and using [Leggings of the Wanton Spellcaster].

compared between the two setups:
using the [Leggings of the Wanton Spellcaster] i was above the hit cap so i was able to regem for 19sp and also got more haste than the gauntlet/valor legs combo.
however with the gauntlets/valor legs i got almost 1.5% more crit.

the spellpower difference was not that noticable maybe only 20 more sp.

the two things i could tell was hate and crit.

what do you guys recomend?

Offline
Old 03/06/09, 8:30 AM   #529
Curtis
Von Kaiser
 
Curtis's Avatar
 
Dwarf Hunter
 
Vol'jin (EU)
I think 20sp + some haste > 1.5%crit.

And you still have ~15/20 spare hit (for a futur bracer change or...)

Offline
Old 03/06/09, 12:42 PM   #530
Infuri
Von Kaiser
 
Orc Shaman
 
Dalaran
Removing this, sorry, didn't realize [Battlemaster's Accuracy] was in the spreadsheet, i'll go back to excel.

Last edited by Infuri : 03/06/09 at 12:59 PM.

Offline
Old 03/06/09, 7:32 PM   #531
Ezareth
Don Flamenco
 
Goblin Mage
 
Tichondrius
Originally Posted by Mmootimus View Post
Thank you for testing.

I spent several hours today at the target dummy, trying to get a handle on just what is going on with LB mechanics.

My conclusions, which some may not agree with, are:

1. Glyph of LB is additive, and not multiplicative with concussion, so together they give a 1.09 multiplier.
2. Totem of Hex is bugged, and is possibly not benefiting from Shamanism, rather than being short on spellpower.
Ok I did my definitive testing and confirmed the following (would have posted them last night but for whatever reason I was banned for "improper punctuation")

Glyph of LB IS additive to concussion.

Totem of Hex or Shamanism is Bugged as Shamanism does not affect the 165 spellpower gained from Totem of Hex.

Here are my testing results, each test involved 150-200 lightning bolt to assume beyond a reasonable doubt the accuracy.

Base Untalented LB 719-819
With Totem of Hex , max hit was 936

Base LB 719-819
Talented Shamanism only.
With Totem of Hex, max hit was 936

Base LB 755-860
With Concussion and Shamanism
With Totem of Hexm max hit was 984

Base LB 783-893
With Concussion, Glyph of Lightning Bolt and Shamanism
WithTotem of Hex max hit was 1021

Glyph of Lightning Bolt and Concussion both work perfectly with Totem of Hex, but it seems Shamanism is not truly increasing the coefficient by .1, either that or Totem of Hexs damabe is added at some point before shamanism is calculated or something.

This costs us 18 damage to our lightning bolts.

Offline
Old 03/07/09, 1:39 PM   #532
JoeHeff
Glass Joe
 
Troll Shaman
 
Bronzebeard
Ring + belt?

<-- Armory, of course.
Right now I'm trying to decide about upgrading my ring.
A) signet of the malevolent, keep current belt and replace heroic ring with KT ring?
B) drop emblems on sash and replace northern tears with KT ring?
C) roll on +hit belt from thaddius (25 man) and replace northern tears with KT ring?
D) other? (wait in line for haste+spell power cloth gear like belt and such, keeping northern tears or getting 10 man hit ring?)

For reference, loot rules in my guild:
Cloth is prioritized to clothies, EXCEPT those with +hit on them (ie wanton)
Anything with mp5 is prioritized to healers (ie torch)

Any input on the best combo to upgrade the northern tears ring would be appreciated!

Offline
Old 03/07/09, 2:00 PM   #533
Bigalicious
Glass Joe
 
Draenei Shaman
 
Chromaggus
Question :)

just trying to get an outsiders point of view. my current gear set up seems to be the max sp-haste-crit i can muster atm while keeping my hit. i have fallout, girdle, wraith, and war prisoner in the bank as well as hero's gloves maxed with hit. just want to see what you guys think? see anything that i might could switch? or possibly a regem/enchant i am not thinking about? i have read a lot about the maly 10 cloth chest, but nothing about the 10man 4h chest which is similar. ( im wearing atm)i have been the MT for my guild since t5 content, and am thinking about making the imfamous transition from alt to main. ele's are just too fun. i have tanking down to a science, but this ranged caster business is rather new to me. thanks in advance for whatever help you can offer.

this being my first post, i wanted to add that what you guys have researched on this site, and in this thread is an amazing thing and you guys are an invaluable part of this game..so thanks!!

Offline
Old 03/07/09, 2:11 PM   #534
Curtis
Von Kaiser
 
Curtis's Avatar
 
Dwarf Hunter
 
Vol'jin (EU)
Originally Posted by JoeHeff View Post
<-- Armory, of course.
Right now I'm trying to decide about upgrading my ring.
A) signet of the malevolent, keep current belt and replace heroic ring with KT ring?
B) drop emblems on sash and replace northern tears with KT ring?
C) roll on +hit belt from thaddius (25 man) and replace northern tears with KT ring?
D) other? (wait in line for haste+spell power cloth gear like belt and such, keeping northern tears or getting 10 man hit ring?)
[...]
C : you gain max spellpower and can't expect better than dropping crit for hit (badge belt for mail belt)

Then try to get the malevolent to switch back to belt mail.



@Big : i would switch the shield for the badge offhand and spend some badges for T7 chest.

Last edited by Curtis : 03/07/09 at 2:20 PM.

Offline
Old 03/07/09, 2:38 PM   #535
fischsemmel
Glass Joe
 
Draenei Shaman
 
Kel'Thuzad
Armory: The World of Warcraft Armory
2:38 patch kill: Wow Web Stats
3:01 patch kill: Wow Web Stats


I've read through this entire thread repeatedly, tried working through my gear, spec, rotation, etc., by myself. However, I haven't made any progress. I have yet to top 5k on patch despite our recent patch kill that got down to almost 2:30. In the last 4-5 weeks I have only seen one upgrade (valorous helm up from heroes), and have been right around 4800 dps on patch every week.

I'm getting pretty damn frustrated because I get the feeling that I should be able to break 5k with my gear.

Can I do more to increase my dps, or am I at a point where only better gear or less latency can improve my damage?

Offline
Old 03/07/09, 3:25 PM   #536
Curtis
Von Kaiser
 
Curtis's Avatar
 
Dwarf Hunter
 
Vol'jin (EU)
@fischsemmel :
Spent some time on your wws and I may miss something (have not used excel nor match your wws versus other people)but can't find anything except no potion of speed use. Did you had flask/spell power food ?

Anyway you could still have some 'easy' upgrades on your stuff/template :
*+23 haste for your back
*+63 sp for your weapon
*rare LK gem for belt
*+10 stats on chest and +10% int talent (int -> crit)

Offline
Old 03/07/09, 3:32 PM   #537
JoeHeff
Glass Joe
 
Troll Shaman
 
Bronzebeard
Fisch - what was your latency? Looking at the 2:38 kill that you posted, I think you'll find that you're going to get the same response that several before you have gotten, which is that your LvB's are average of ~10.27 seconds apart, and you should be able to tighten that up.

Here's my last Patch kill, Wow Web Stats with almost exactly same dps time. Our gear looks pretty similar (this was before I got the sarth trinket, you can check my gear/stats and compare the rest. My crit% is a bit higher, and I also popped a speed pot during bloodlust.

Hope the comparison helps.

Edit: I didn't go through to analyze the LO procs on yours, hell I got lost trying to count them on my own report. If I counted correctly, I had about 18% (so slightly bad luck with RNG I guess). You can check your combat log with spell="lightning bolt" and source="<your name>" and count how many look like LO procs and compare to the total number of LB's. Not sure if there is an easier way to do it, but that's one way to find out if you just fell victim to the RNG.

Offline
Old 03/07/09, 7:40 PM   #538
fischsemmel
Glass Joe
 
Draenei Shaman
 
Kel'Thuzad
Thanks, Curtis. I actually did know of all those potential boosts, but I have some lazy moments And yeah, I was rolling with flask of the frost wyrm and fish feast for consumables.


Joe - WoW claims my latency is almost always under 100 (mousing over my options button). I use quartz as a castbar mod though, and it says that in combat on raid bosses my latency is rarely below 200, often as high as 600-700... probably averaging between 300 and 400 on most nights.


I can't remember if this was regarding the two WWS that I posted or others of mine that I've looked at, but I think I had somewhere around 18 seconds of DPS time without flameshock up. Also I think that tightening up my rotation would basically allow me to have an extra LvB cast, but I think that would be coming at the cost of 1.2 seconds of casting a LB. Fixing these two problems alone will not even boost my DPS on the fight by 100 (if thinking about it in my head a bit is accurate).

It's not that I am in denial that the little things (slightly better enchants, replacing my 16 SP gem, squeezing in one more LvB in a 2 minute fight, a speed pot, etc.) will boost my DPS... but they are such small upgrades that even if I am RIGHT on top of all of them, I'm still not going to get over 5k unless there is more factoring in (like my guild puts together a 2:00 kill or something).

Is my combination of latency and gear just not going to let me get much higher than I am at right now, no matter how perfectly my rotation, enchants, etc., are?

Offline
Old 03/08/09, 10:04 AM   #539
Mmootimus
Piston Honda
 
Mmootimus's Avatar
 
Tauren Shaman
 
Quel'Thalas (EU)
Originally Posted by fischsemmel View Post
Fixing these two problems alone will not even boost my DPS on the fight by 100 (if thinking about it in my head a bit is accurate).

It's not that I am in denial that the little things (slightly better enchants, replacing my 16 SP gem, squeezing in one more LvB in a 2 minute fight, a speed pot, etc.) will boost my DPS... but they are such small upgrades that even if I am RIGHT on top of all of them, I'm still not going to get over 5k unless there is more factoring in (like my guild puts together a 2:00 kill or something).

Is my combination of latency and gear just not going to let me get much higher than I am at right now, no matter how perfectly my rotation, enchants, etc., are?
I would say your DPS for your current gear level is pretty respectable, not stunning, but nothing to be ashamed of.

The main issue for me, is your hit cap. Assuming those two WWS are representative, you always have at least one SPriest, in which case you can drop around 80 hit. A simple upgrade would therefore be to hit the AH for some Benefactor's Gauntlets.

As for the enchants, gems and talent build, I think fixing them will have more effect than you think. And with a tightened rotation I do think it would push you over 5k. If you want to be a little lazy with your character around the edges its no great crime in the overall scheme of things, but you may not be on the right website .

Offline
Old 03/09/09, 12:11 AM   #540
Cyrella
Glass Joe
 
Draenei Shaman
 
Proudmoore
Im right in the same boat as Fisch, I hover around 4.8-4.9k on my patch kills, I have hit 5.1k on a Raz kill. Its probably my 200ish ms latency that is keeping my rotation from being tighter. For elemental is a speed pot better or is wild magic better? I have been using wild magic pots.

I still have a few slots that aren't BiS yet (still need voice of reason, eruption scarred boots, signet of manifested pain, and pennant cloak).

Offline
Closed Thread

Go Back   Elitist Jerks » Class Mechanics » Shamans

Thread Tools

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
[Druid] Gearing Your End ame Tree Machia The Dung Heap 1 11/11/07 10:31 AM
[Warlock] Gearing up for PvP Tors Player vs. Player 8 10/02/07 9:40 PM
gearing for the arena Malan Public Discussion 26 02/23/07 12:43 PM
Gearing up for raiding Mesquite Public Discussion 28 12/02/05 6:16 PM