Hi there!
Well, this is my first forum post in here. I've been looking in these threads quite often and very smart guys already asked, simcrafted and solved my questions. I'm sry for my bad english btw.
Back to topic
At the moment, i am looking forward to get a few trinkets from raids. And as i was looking through endless best in slot lists in forums, simcraft, rawr and so on I found this trinket quite often rated as BIS:
Heart of Ignatious
And i really don't know if i can trust simcrafts bis list or rawr.
Well, its a good stacking passive SP boost of 435 (you have to stack up often, so a little less) and additional, you've got 1815 haste with a cd of 2 minutes.
So, you've got ~400 Sp and 302,5 Haste all over the fight.
Let's compare to almost every trinket with int on int like Theralions mirror or even Witching Hourglass.
With int scaling three times better than haste and spellpower scaling nearly double times better than haste, every trinket with ~300 int on and any! secondary stat (even Darkmooncard: Volcano or Tyrandes favorite doll) would be better than the heart. And in nhc gear, i wont be able to get to the next haste-tick-cap.
Is there any brainlag in this statement?
To give this discussion some numbers:
DPS Gain for Various Trinkets
Assuming scale factors taken from ej for bis, might be slightly different on nhc lvl but not to much:
int=3,17, SP=2,39, haste=0,76, crit=1,18, mast=1,01
Heart of Ignatious (~350 SP and ~267 haste allover the fight): 1041
Witching Hourglass (285 Int and 342 haste allover the fight): 1164
Theralions Mirror (321 Int and 428 mastery all over the fight): 1451,01
Darkmooncard: Volcano (193 Mastery, 128 Crit (reforged), 320 int all over the fight, WITHOUT firedmgproc): 1361