I was just wondering in regards to furys rotation, if i BT > CS get a bloodsurge proc but have no raging blow available or anyway to proc it what should I be using. At the moment I'm using Heroic throw and battle shout to fill globals before the CS to have as much rage ready to dump inside it, but a few times ive been in this situation and if I use Wildstrike I would delay BT, the only option I have seems to be to heroic strike for a global or something.

I don't think that's correct. From the Prot thread:

Mastery seems to be superior regardless. And as for there being no cap, maybe you aren't quite aware of the implications. Say you have 50% parry and 0% dodge and you have the option to reforge parry on your gear. Should you be reforging it to dodge to try to correct the ratio between dodge and parry or should you reforge it to mastery because it's still superior? And where exactly is the breaking point?

Mastery rating gives a smaller percentage of block chance than parry and dodge ratings give avoidance chance (although it might be slightly higher after diminishing returns), and block chance only gives 30% damage reduction unlike parry and dodge which completely avoid the attack. In fights where you don't use Shield Block, the increased critical block chance of mastery does nothing (since you can only crit block while Shield Block is active), and makes mastery almost useless in comparison to parry and dodge.

The quote from the Prot thread doesn't mention anything about this. It only puts the stats in order based on some simulation, which presumably uses Shield Block as I don't see any other reason why mastery would be above parry and dodge.

The cap I mentioned (getting too much rage) is just a soft cap that drops the value of that stat at that point. It never becomes useless (as long as you are using Shield Block).

TL;DR: You can only critically block while Shield Block is active, which makes mastery almost useless in fights where using Shield Block is not beneficial.

EDIT: Not true, see below.

Any block can be a critical block, no matter whether you are using shield block or not.
If you use Shield Block, mastery only gives us low benefit on the block (as shield block should be up ~66% of the time and thus only 33% of the time block is buffed by mastery). However, it gives us a high benefit for critical blocks, as we are blocking quite often.
If we are not using Shield Block, it exactly switches sides: Strong benefit for block chance, less for critical block.

So with the Legendary Gem out, which is the best Weapon Comp for SMF?

Choosing between (heroic) Elegion, (reg/heroic) Scimitar, and (reg) Kilrak. What will be the best MH/OH combo....

My first guess is, for the MH, (heroic) Elegion, replacing with (heroic) Scimitar once received, with the gemmed Kilrak in the OH. (Or would it be better to use (reg) Scimitar over (heroic) Elegion until (heroic) Scimitar?)

What's making me ask this is the fact that you will be able to gem a prismatic socket in the Sha-Touched Weapons come 5.1.... Would (reg) Kilrak be better in the MH with the extra gem socket, gemming for crit of course? Would it beat (heroic) Elegion, but not (heroic) Scimitar, or would it beat both? Or maybe, even with the gem bonuses, that you go (heroic) Scimitar in MH and OH until (heroic) Kilrak? (Although I think the latter will be highly unlikely come 5.1.)

Thank you very much.

Elegion: [Elegion, the Fanged Crescent]
Scimitar: [Scimitar of Seven Stars]/[Scimitar of Seven Stars]
Kilrak: [Kilrak, Jaws of Terror]

If you include the prismatic socket on Kilrak, the most recent stat weights I've seen put it as H Scimitar > N Kilrak > H Elegion > N Scimitar.

H Scimitar in your main hand and N Kilrak in your off hand is most likely the best option for you.

That is for all races that don't have a weapon-specific racial bonus, of course. Orcs would move H Elegion above N Kilrak, though I think that's the only significant change there.

Keep in mind, of course, that these weightings can be somewhat subjective based on how much over the expertise cap (and to a lesser extent, hit cap) you find yourself with your gear. If you're unable to reforge low enough, or forced to reforge into subpar stats like Mastery, that may push things around a bit. It's likely, though, that that won't come into play much if at all this tier, at least insofar as to effect weapon ratings.

I've been a mouse clicker for years, and using the keyboard to move around. But in watching tank videos from the big boys, I seldom see the mouse, so I'm assuming keyboarding with special key binds, macros, etc. Would anyone be willing to share their strategy in the layout, macros, key bindings, and utilization of these for tanking? I feel like I'm spending too much time looking at buttons to click and missing things I need to watch.

Thanks

I do the same as Berthold. It does suck for Heroic Leap but otherwise I quite like it since you don't often need twitchy movement in PvE.

A mouse with some more Buttons + shift, alt and ctrl bindings on it, could help.
3 buttons which are activated by the thumb let you get 12 skills/makros,
right and left mouseclick would give you 6 skills/makros without changing their normal behavior.

So you get easy 18 buttons on a mouse which just has 3 buttons near your thumb *thumbs up*

Hello,
IN which hand shall i put my stronger weapon? off hand for WS oder main hand?
greetings

Theck did an awesome post a while ago over on sacredduty, explaining his key layout and some advantages/disadvantages. Even though I can't get myself to change my binds, maybe some of his ideas will help you:
UI Construction and Key Bindings | Sacred Duty