http://www.ekagaming.com/landsoul/Wa...ODIFIEDv2.xlsm

For a bit more reliable download if anyone was wanting this to hold them over till landsoul finishes the offical 3.3 ss

I strongly caution using any modified SS right now. A majority of the trinkets and procs will not operate properly and suggest incorrect gearing decisions. Also, you will want to gear around new hit table assumptions which probably won't be included in a modded SS of the old version.

Well, you're the expert. What changes to the hit table are you referring to though?

I THINK he's refering to the 4.8% crit supression against raid bosses discussed in Retesting hit table assumptions but that's not really new... so I could be mistaken.

Same gear on both SS (Landsoul and the modified version) giving me two VERY different results. Have you done anything else but to add items, brandorf?

The example i'm talking about:

When I add, on Landsoul's spreadsheet, [Citadel Enforcer's Claymore] to my off-hand slot, it gives me more DPS then [Ramaladni's Blade of Culling]. But on brandorf's version, it gives me the opposite results.

Following the off-hand weapon guidelines, [Citadel Enforcer's Claymore] would be better, but this got me somehow confused.

My understanding is that it has nothing to do with the RECENT update to the model. Before the model said (as is implemented in the SS) to substract the 4.8%, but in your OP example, if you had 54.8% base crit, than the overpower crit % would be 54.8%+50%-4.8% = 100%. Under new model, the crit % BEFORE substracting 4.8% cannot exceed 100%, so the new crit would be still 95.2% - and it would NEVER go higher.

I was doing some research the other day on the Deathbringer's Will trinket and its procs after reading some of the posts on this thread. I don't believe it is going to be BiS for Fury or Arms. It has a ~29% uptime (1min 45 icd with 30 second buff) with a chance of 3 different procs. For warriors this is 600 Arp, 600 Crit rating and 600 Str.

One of these procs is worthless at passive ArP cap. Another (crit) is partially ignored because most fury warriors are near the Crit cap raid buffed (55% if you have 5% hit: 25% glancing and 20% miss) and this buff adds 13.07% crit rating. However, this is only a problem for white crits. The crit proc still affects yellow attacks so it's not really a big deal, but still something to consider.

Even so, with a sizable portion of the procs being partially or completely useless, it seems to me (assuming you can hard cap ArP without it) that double Death's Choice or heroic DC with one of the new trinkets (maybe tiny abom tho it has a lot of hit and nothing is known about the proc rate on motes, herkuml's war totem, or even whispering fanged skull) would be better.

You'll only get a handful of procs in any fight with the long ICD, and bad RNG could make for some major head bashing.

Let me know what you guys think.

Did you remember to change your reaction time, latency, and raid buffs to match in both sheets? As far as I know all he did was add items.


35% proc chance.

Yep, everything has been checked, latency, reaction, raid buffs, talents, everything. They are all equal. And since i'm currently going from Arms to Fury, i'm having a "hard time" understanding all the mechanic behind MH and OH choices.

I was being careful to only add the items themselves and not change the calculations. One thing that I have changed for my personal use is that I use a custom rotation as opposed to the standard, you can change it back on the dropdown on H36.

I see about 15% uptime on my NES according to procodile. This syncs up to a ~10% chance on crit. Lowest ICD I've seen is 49 seconds, so it's likely 45 seconds like most trinkets. Wearing both it and a GT at the same time and whacking a target dummy for a while shows the GT at almost 20% uptime, as it procs 15% on hit.