Scorpion already loses to Runestone in all situations hands down, so this argument is moot in the first place. Once you get passed the point where DV is better than Runestone from the opportunity of passive penetration, then Scorption is then out of the question. ~900 ArP + 245 DV barely edges out of 735 ArP + Runestone setup in the first place from what we have seen in TOC.

Also, what's the proc chance on connect of the Axe's thing? 10%?

Page: LOOKUP
Error Type: TYPO
[Darkmaw Crossbow] - showing 43 agility instead of 35

Page: FURY(?)
Error Type: ?
[Legplates of Ascension] - The yellow socket is bugged. I can't activate the socket bonus unless I gem the yellow socket with Nightmare Tear.

Could you please explain this, I don't believe it. I have a hunch that you lowered the swing speed but didn't adjust the low-end and top-end damage to compensate, thus generating a weapon with a higher DPS in the process.

I thought slower weapon speed benefits fury warriors due to WW.

You are entirely correct. I saw the SEP for .1 speed as -0.2, and wondered how that came to be. I changed the weapon speed myself and saw that it did in fact lower overall DPS, not realizing that it decreased the DPS on the weapon because DPS isn't a stored value.

[Edit] - Post removed as its content is now invalid

Does anyone else have problems reading this and older versions in Windows 7?
I'm unable to run it, because it says "file is corrupt", and fixing it destroy the macros. I've been using it perfectly in XP and Vista (both x64).

Thanks for any help in the matter.

So Shadow's Edge got datamined yesterday and putting in the stats it comes out as a 173 DPS increase over Dual-Blade Butcher.

Stat comparison over DBB:

.1 Speed decrease
61-92 Weapon Damage increase
13 DPS increase
27 Strength increase
11 Stamina increase
Red Socket instead of Blue Socket so +6 strength
2 Crit and 2 Armor Pen loss

The proc for shadowmourne also got changed to become a 40 strength stacking proc for 10 stacks and a 2k damage meaning 400 strength for however long the proc is making that a very nice proc when you upgrade the weapon.

If we go by adding straight 40 strength to the spreadsheet it comes out as a 93 DPS upgrade for me. 400 Strength closing in on close to 1k and the 2k damage is also a small damage increase. Assuming with 2 second attack speed and 50% chance to proc it'd take about 20 seconds from just white hits assuming no missing or dodges and guessing 10 second proc uptime with 30-45 second icd, making the proc alone a very nice change compared to the old 7k hit.

Well it looks like we're going to be able to hit all 4 hard caps (expertise, hit, armor pen, and crit) as fury with only the 277 set and the 264 gear. Too bad our set bonuses aren't too great compared to other classes.

If only they changed bloodsurge to work like sudden doom then the 4 piece would be extremly nice.

At least now we have 3 BiS tier peices from the 277 set (ArP pieces) and the 4th one can be decided once we see which offset pieces with hit & expertise qualify as BiS. One major flaw in the 4-pieces set bonus is why blizzard still havnt granted slam the ability to come off GCD when bloodsurge procs. While reducing the GCD by 2/3 and doubling the buff duration, by not allowing the buff to accumilate past 2 from the set bonus and still being restricted by the GCD were still going to find situations where we hold off to use higher priority abilties and in turn these may trigger wasted bloodsurge procs.

DPS/SEP values for Set Bonuses.

I've seen a lot of questions about how to download the spreadsheet from filefront and no answers. I am wanting to get this for my warrior, is there any other source for the download? I have tried to download this file probably 15 times now and it gets to roughly 500 kb and stops the download.

Anyone have a clue? I am clicking "save" not just "open".

In all honesty I don't see why we won't be able to make all 5 pieces work unless there are better leather or mail equivalents. There's only hit and expertise on one piece each and we still need those to cap out on avoidance.

Also, the problem with SEP for bonuses is implementation. You can't split them evenly across each item, because you only need 4 out of 5 and 2 out of 5 and there are many combinations of choosing what to wear for those bonii. If you chose to wear all 5 pieces, and the bonii were split into 4 across each of the 5 items, there would be an overestimation for the 5th piece, which could be either of the 5. Same thing if you chose to wear 3/5 for the 2 bonus. You can't split the 2 piece DPS across 3 pieces. Which pieces would you give it to? The only way I can think is a button that will allow the finding of change in DPS of the set bonii based on your stats and it being posted somewhere for quick reference on the lookup page.

Also, I still am aware of the demand for the '97 version. I have found a solution to the cell limitation problem for '97, but it involves formatting the lookup page a different way to be able to fit more columns per item before reaching the column limit for '97, effectively splitting up the DPS, SEP, and DPS diff column into three different columns. This will allow cross-compatibility of the same spreadsheet release across both excel platforms.

Also, please don't forget that I am always accepting donations as updating this massive spreadsheet on time and making it better with each rendition requires a lot of hard work and time spent. Check the first post on how to do so in case you don't know already.

Yes this is correct

Landsoul - can you please put Shadowmourne - Items - Sigrie in to sheet?

You can easily add it with the current build and the proc can be measured by adding 40 strength per stack the 2k damage i cant measure however as proc rate and how there applied is unkown.

To anyone who would like to use the spreadsheet, but is unable to due to lack of software; Microsoft has made the beta test of Office 2010 available to the public. You can get it here. I have tried it, and so far everything works (SEP, Armory import, DPS).

Excel 2010

"Microsoft Excel Web App. Edit documents in a Web browser when you’re away from your office, home, or school without compromising the quality of your viewing experience."

"Co-authoring through the Microsoft Excel Web App makes it possible for you to edit the same spreadsheet with others simultaneously from different locations. You can see who’s working on a spreadsheet with you at the same time. All modifications are instantly shown and flagged so you can see where others are editing and who those editors are."

Interesting. I will be most excited about the Web App. I won't have to be on my home machine to make modifications. Also others with 2010 can apparently log into the web app and view the spreadsheet online.

I have noticed that weapon speed values in the fury dps spreadsheet are not adjusted by the user's chosen increment. This means that a change of .1 weapon speed is always used no matter how huge of increases your other stats are getting. So even if you use a large increment where each stat affects your dps by a huge amount your weapon speed is still having the same piddly effect.

In effect, doubling your increment divides the effect of weapon speed by two. All you have to do to fix this is to multiply cells C102 and C104 (the weapon speed cells) by D26 (the increment cell).

Also, is there any way we can calculate weapon damage in SEP? Higher item level items will have higher weapon dps, which is definitely good, but the item might still not be an upgrade if it isn't itemized quite right. It'd be nice to check.

TY for all the hard work.

That's already there but the weapon speed SEP has been bugged as you said with higher (other than 1) increments. The fix is listed on the errors section on the front page.

Landsoul's Horned Greathelm - Items - Sigrie

Gratz Landsoul!

Theres the bit of T10 that you can drop :P
Will make sure to donate after 3.3 sheet release. TBH I find the sheet almost as fun as actually playing wow

Not quite sure about dropping that bit of t10 personally as there are other pieces which aren't set pieces that have hit on them. Far too much plate gear found so far having hit/arp or exp/arp most likely to keep crit rates down.

On another note, Congrats landsoul on your item. Recognition for the significant contribution you've made to the warrior community. A much deserved reward.