Elitist Jerks » Search Forums Search Results

Username Remember me? Password

Showing results 1 to 33 of 33 Search took 0 seconds. Search: Posts Made By: Phatha

Forum: Priests 09/28/09, 10:02 PM

Replies: 1,039 WotLK Healing Compendium v3.2: Same Old Thing Views: 926,526 Posted By Phatha Having downed the first two bosses in TOC-25 on... Having downed the first two bosses in TOC-25 on hard mode and cleared 10man hard mode multiple times, there's no way I'd be stacking int. I don't stack pure spell power either because I feel like a...

Forum: Priests 08/30/09, 10:00 PM

Replies: 864 WotLK Healing Discussion v3.2: Ulduar and Coliseum Views: 474,566 Posted By Phatha Having healed Faction Champions on 10 and 25... Having healed Faction Champions on 10 and 25 modes, I haven't felt the need to even attempt going Disc. With all the fun instant heal tools in the Holy arsenal, I haven't had any problems with...

Forum: Warriors 07/17/09, 1:41 PM

Replies: 921 Finalizing the Prot Warrior design Views: 688,793 Posted By Phatha Revenge hits significantly harder the last time I... Revenge hits significantly harder the last time I looked. And as long as revenge is marginally better, it's going to be higher on the priority list for tanks. However, he closer they make devastate...

Forum: Warriors 06/22/09, 12:12 AM

Replies: 921 Finalizing the Prot Warrior design Views: 688,793 Posted By Phatha Speaking of hard-modes, our 10man run completed... Speaking of hard-modes, our 10man run completed Vezax hard mode this week. A blood DK tank makes all the other tanks look ridiculously bad on that fight. With all of the typical DK cooldowns along...

Forum: Warriors 06/20/09, 2:00 AM

Replies: 921 Finalizing the Prot Warrior design Views: 688,793 Posted By Phatha Removing block from gear and having it come... Removing block from gear and having it come solely from Str is an interesting idea. It would remove some of the flavors of tank gear, but we already seem to have a lot of those (ie. items with hit,...

Forum: Warriors 06/16/09, 7:45 PM

Replies: 921 Finalizing the Prot Warrior design Views: 688,793 Posted By Phatha Yes a warrior is a great tank but when you only... Yes a warrior is a great tank but when you only need 1 tank for the fight, then a warrior doesn't bring much to the table as an OT. Especially compared to the dps a feral druid can bring. The buffs...

Forum: Warriors 06/14/09, 9:03 PM

Replies: 2,923 Warrior DPS Calculation Spreadsheet Views: 3,330,191 Posted By Phatha To Shha: Weapon mastery is showing 0 points. To... To Shha: Weapon mastery is showing 0 points. To Sentia: Obviously I know that 26 expertise is preferable... That's why I'm asking the question in the first place. To Vashar: Yes I reclicked the...

Forum: Warriors 06/14/09, 2:09 AM

Replies: 2,923 Warrior DPS Calculation Spreadsheet Views: 3,330,191 Posted By Phatha Well, I'm fury, wielding Ironsoul/Stormedge and... Well, I'm fury, wielding Ironsoul/Stormedge and character sheet in game is showing 23/20 expertise. So I'm definitely below the expertise cap. Spreadsheet is showing 23 expertise with 3 from racial...

Forum: Warriors 06/13/09, 7:32 PM

Replies: 2,923 Warrior DPS Calculation Spreadsheet Views: 3,330,191 Posted By Phatha I just picked up new bracers and dropped some... I just picked up new bracers and dropped some expertise by doing so. I'm sitting at 21 expertise and adding one Precise Scarlet Ruby (16 exp) only puts me at 23 expertise, but the spreadsheet is...

Forum: Shamans 06/12/09, 5:59 PM

Replies: 1,485 [Resto] Best Practices: PvE Healing Discussion Views: 1,109,779 Posted By Phatha Yeah I looked at my shaman vs my priests healing... Yeah I looked at my shaman vs my priests healing setups and I have significantly fewer active heals available to my shaman. In fact, I've healed 10man Ulduar on both toons and even though my shaman...

Forum: Warriors 06/12/09, 1:47 PM

Replies: 2,923 Warrior DPS Calculation Spreadsheet Views: 3,330,191 Posted By Phatha I'd bet on Dark Matter being the superior trinket... I'd bet on Dark Matter being the superior trinket since crit is generally more useful than haste, for both arms and fury I think. Haste is generally a weak stat for warriors comparatively.

Forum: Shamans 06/11/09, 2:58 AM

Replies: 1,485 [Resto] Best Practices: PvE Healing Discussion Views: 1,109,779 Posted By Phatha If we had more tools at our disposal (like this... If we had more tools at our disposal (like this theoretical aoe heal), then maybe CH wouldn't feel so bad. It would still be very useful on fights where everyone is grouped up, even if it is slow,...

Forum: Warriors 06/02/09, 7:44 PM

Replies: 3,232 In-Depth Fury DPS Discussion Views: 2,611,865 Posted By Phatha Agreed, since I'm already swimming in hit, they... Agreed, since I'm already swimming in hit, they could have buffed any other stat (except maybe stam) and it might have felt worthwhile. As it is, I still have almost no interest in upgrading from...

Forum: Warriors 06/02/09, 7:17 PM

Replies: 3,232 In-Depth Fury DPS Discussion Views: 2,611,865 Posted By Phatha A measly 10 hit rating was added to both... A measly 10 hit rating was added to both shoulders (according to Wowhead comments), so in my book it's a minimal buff at best.

Forum: Warriors 05/29/09, 3:09 AM

Replies: 2,923 Warrior DPS Calculation Spreadsheet Views: 3,330,191 Posted By Phatha Looks like a new option for the belt is Starfall... Looks like a new option for the belt is Starfall Girdle (http://www.worldofraids.com/images/news/algalon-the-observer-loot/starfall%20girdle.jpg). Lose a lot of crit but the same expertise values...

Forum: Warriors 05/21/09, 11:22 PM

Replies: 3,232 In-Depth Fury DPS Discussion Views: 2,611,865 Posted By Phatha Even on the few fights where using Berserker Rage... Even on the few fights where using Berserker Rage is timing dependent, it's still a better bang for your buck than Enrage. The only fight where I know I'm monitoring my Berserker Rage usage is...

Forum: Warriors 05/17/09, 1:48 PM

Replies: 3,232 In-Depth Fury DPS Discussion Views: 2,611,865 Posted By Phatha I actually enjoy the GCD usage of farming more,... I actually enjoy the GCD usage of farming more, simply because we get to use Victory Rush. It's always felt like a neglected ability for fury and I would have much preferred for Bloodsurge to have...

Forum: Warriors 05/04/09, 2:22 AM

Replies: 921 Finalizing the Prot Warrior design Views: 688,793 Posted By Phatha It could be a while before the 4-piece bonus can... It could be a while before the 4-piece bonus can help on Hodir, considering you're more than likely wearing some Icebane pieces as well to tank, which means you'll need everything but T8 chest (I'm...

Forum: Warriors 04/29/09, 1:16 AM

Replies: 3,232 In-Depth Fury DPS Discussion Views: 2,611,865 Posted By Phatha i respecced for 3 points in UW and IBR, along... i respecced for 3 points in UW and IBR, along with frequent usage of bloodrage, and I'm having much fewer problems on the second week in Ulduar. I'm still annoyed that the DK/Pallies are kicking my...

Forum: Warriors 04/24/09, 7:38 PM

Replies: 3,232 In-Depth Fury DPS Discussion Views: 2,611,865 Posted By Phatha Without the big raid buffs like WF/SoE totem/Horn... Without the big raid buffs like WF/SoE totem/Horn of Winter and the comparatively large gains to Fury (compared to Arms), it seems reasonable that Fury would lose to Arms. I'm not positive that...

Forum: Warriors 04/23/09, 6:33 PM

Replies: 3,232 In-Depth Fury DPS Discussion Views: 2,611,865 Posted By Phatha In the same boat as you are. I picked up T8 legs... In the same boat as you are. I picked up T8 legs from a lucky VoA drop, along with several agi->str upgrades over the last week. I'm finding my Strength has skyrocketed but my crit has plummeted. ...

Forum: Warriors 03/05/09, 5:20 PM

Replies: 545 Official 3.1 changes and discussion Views: 281,646 Posted By Phatha That's the point. It's easy to get capped and... That's the point. It's easy to get capped and there's entirely too much plate with expertise. It would be nice if it was useful past the cap, especially since it's itemized on 2 pieces of T7, both...

Forum: Warriors 03/05/09, 4:14 PM

Replies: 545 Official 3.1 changes and discussion Views: 281,646 Posted By Phatha Might be interesting to see an expertise penalty... Might be interesting to see an expertise penalty included instead of a hit/percentage penalty. It would give us all a reason to use those plate pieces (and 2h maces) that are over-itemized with...

Forum: Shamans 03/04/09, 2:55 PM

Replies: 300 [ELEMENTAL] Upcoming changes Views: 103,198 Posted By Phatha I assume you're referencing this post: Emblem of... I assume you're referencing this post: Emblem of Conquest Loot and PTR Testing Schedule (http://www.mmo-champion.com/index.php?topic=42241.0) As far as I can tell, we'll be picking up more cloth...

Forum: Warriors 02/21/09, 2:01 PM

Replies: 921 Finalizing the Prot Warrior design Views: 688,793 Posted By Phatha I'm pretty sure the pally talent was added in... I'm pretty sure the pally talent was added in when they did the item consolidation and removed Spellpower from tanking gear. That way pallies could pick up "warrior" gear and still increase their...

Forum: Warriors 02/20/09, 10:28 PM

Replies: 921 Finalizing the Prot Warrior design Views: 688,793 Posted By Phatha Ahhh but their talent scales in a raid. When... Ahhh but their talent scales in a raid. When pallies get BoK and Fort, that talent gets that extra little buff. We get a buff from stoneskin/devo aura? AttT : 1205 armor * 1.5 (if it's a prot...

Forum: Warriors 02/20/09, 9:54 PM

Replies: 921 Finalizing the Prot Warrior design Views: 688,793 Posted By Phatha Pallies gain threat through mitigation/EH... Pallies gain threat through mitigation/EH already, with their Touched by the Light talent (deep prot). It also increases their healing capabilities. It doesn't seem unreasonable that there be a...

Forum: Warriors 02/18/09, 4:37 PM

Replies: 921 Finalizing the Prot Warrior design Views: 688,793 Posted By Phatha Yeah sorry, meant that to read like a Puncture... Yeah sorry, meant that to read like a Puncture change would benefit OT threat/dps. A change to Imp Heroic Strike would be negligible increase in OT threat/dps if we're not getting hit. I'll change...

Forum: Warriors 02/18/09, 3:59 PM

Replies: 921 Finalizing the Prot Warrior design Views: 688,793 Posted By Phatha Right now Puncture is largely a useless talent... Right now Puncture is largely a useless talent with the 1/2/3 rage reduction on Devastate, which is by far one of our weakest threat abilities. Wouldn't it be preferable to change the -1/2/3 rage to...

Forum: Warriors 02/17/09, 11:45 AM

Replies: 921 Finalizing the Prot Warrior design Views: 688,793 Posted By Phatha I'm liking all the discussion about new talents... I'm liking all the discussion about new talents that would add rend dmg or increase the weapon dmg component on devastate but wouldn't this lead to the exact opposite problem we have right now? That...

Forum: Warriors 02/16/09, 11:46 AM

Replies: 921 Finalizing the Prot Warrior design Views: 688,793 Posted By Phatha They changed it to AP and nerfed the amount... They changed it to AP and nerfed the amount gained from armor but all 3 warrior talent specs still pick it up, so it's still mandatory. Making it Str only allows it to gain from BoK and increase...

Forum: Warriors 02/16/09, 11:29 AM

Replies: 921 Finalizing the Prot Warrior design Views: 688,793 Posted By Phatha How do raid buffs increase warrior threat... How do raid buffs increase warrior threat generation? Pallies will gain extra threat through Stam->Spellpower conversions when they get Fort/BoK (not sure about DK/druid). Warriors will gain...

Forum: Warriors 02/09/09, 2:29 PM

Replies: 921 Finalizing the Prot Warrior design Views: 688,793 Posted By Phatha In response to the discussion Liar and Jayde are... In response to the discussion Liar and Jayde are having, perhaps having Vigilance on the MT proc both Revenge and Overpower would be a more well-rounded solution. Since you can't really use both at...

Showing results 1 to 33 of 33