Elitist Jerks » Search Forums Search Results

Username Remember me? Password

Showing results 1 to 22 of 22 Search took 0.01 seconds. Search: Posts Made By: A1win

Forum: Warriors 12/10/12, 4:38 PM

Replies: 139 [MoP] Protection Warrior Views: 170,605 Posted By A1win No, you'd still get parried 7.5% of the time with... No, you'd still get parried 7.5% of the time with 7.5% hit and 7.5% expertise, or miss 7.5% of the time with 0% hit and 15% expertise. It just means that 7.5% hit 7.5% exp and 0% hit 15% exp would...

Forum: Warriors 12/07/12, 5:19 PM

Replies: 139 [MoP] Protection Warrior Views: 170,605 Posted By A1win Hands seemed to have the highest difference when... Hands seemed to have the highest difference when comparing stat weight scores of T14 pieces to off-set pieces for each slot. The differences for other pieces were so small that I'm pretty sure the...

Forum: Warriors 12/03/12, 12:08 PM

Replies: 139 [MoP] Protection Warrior Views: 170,605 Posted By A1win Is there any data comparing Dancing Steel and... Is there any data comparing Dancing Steel and River's Song to the weapon chain? Quick napkin math tells me that Dancing Steel gives you an "average" of 290 Strength, which is even before diminishing...

Forum: Warriors 11/30/12, 11:54 AM

Replies: 139 [MoP] Protection Warrior Views: 170,605 Posted By A1win A health bar that depletes slower means that you... A health bar that depletes slower means that you have more time before you die, and more importantly, your healers have more time to react to your health bar depleting. This doesn't take healer mana...

Forum: Warriors 11/21/12, 10:20 AM

Replies: 139 [MoP] Protection Warrior Views: 170,605 Posted By A1win I still believe that expertise only affects dodge... I still believe that expertise only affects dodge and parry chance and hit only affects miss chance. They are still practically exactly identical until caps, even though they are technically...

Forum: Warriors 11/20/12, 12:08 PM

Replies: 546 Sticky: [Cataclysm] Warrior: Simple Questions/Simple Answers Views: 725,846 Posted By A1win Alright, I got confused by Shield Block tooltip... Alright, I got confused by Shield Block tooltip where it specifically mentions "These blocks can be critical blocks." and by not noticing ever becoming enraged without Shield Block on (due to low...

Forum: Warriors 11/20/12, 7:55 AM

Replies: 546 Sticky: [Cataclysm] Warrior: Simple Questions/Simple Answers Views: 725,846 Posted By A1win Mastery rating gives a smaller percentage of... Mastery rating gives a smaller percentage of block chance than parry and dodge ratings give avoidance chance (although it might be slightly higher after diminishing returns), and block chance only...

Forum: Warriors 11/14/12, 7:24 AM

Replies: 546 Sticky: [Cataclysm] Warrior: Simple Questions/Simple Answers Views: 725,846 Posted By A1win Mastery is only useful for fights where you use... Mastery is only useful for fights where you use Shield Block, which is fights where the bosses hit damage that can be blocked so often that Shield Block becomes better than Shield Barrier. In such...

Forum: The Dung Heap 11/08/12, 8:17 PM

Replies: 30,097 Thread of Ultimate Stupidity Views: 1,873,318 Posted By A1win I'm currently prioritizing sta > exp=hit >... I'm currently prioritizing sta > exp=hit > mastery > parry > dodge (but not gemming for stamina as gems give so little of it, and mastery is worse than parry and dodge in fights where shield block...

Forum: User Interface and AddOns 11/04/12, 10:55 AM

Replies: 2,727 Sticky: UI Help Center Views: 474,265 Posted By A1win Sweet, seems exactly what I should've been... Sweet, seems exactly what I should've been looking for all along. One addon to rule them all! ProtWarBar can't do colored text based on rage amount. It only colors the bar, and that has preset rage...

Forum: Warriors 11/02/12, 9:54 PM

Replies: 139 [MoP] Protection Warrior Views: 170,605 Posted By A1win Taking Vengeance from the MT to the OT doesn't do... Taking Vengeance from the MT to the OT doesn't do anything to raid DPS. You shouldn't be worrying about that because it's just the way the game works. Just let the rest of the raid realize that too...

Forum: Warriors 10/24/12, 10:27 PM

Replies: 139 [MoP] Protection Warrior Views: 170,605 Posted By A1win The last 7.5% expertise is just as useful as the... The last 7.5% expertise is just as useful as the first 7.5% expertise (as was discussed earlier). Why would you get it to 7.5% instead of, let's say, 5%, or 10%? Shouldn't it either be 0% or 15%? The...

Forum: Warriors 10/20/12, 7:45 AM

Replies: 139 [MoP] Protection Warrior Views: 170,605 Posted By A1win Ah, that makes things easier then. So in other... Ah, that makes things easier then. So in other words, expertise becomes better after the "soft cap" for tanks (and it doesn't make sense to call it a "soft cap" anymore), since removing a parry also...

Forum: Warriors 10/19/12, 5:51 AM

Replies: 139 [MoP] Protection Warrior Views: 170,605 Posted By A1win The last 7.5% expertise is only half as valuable... The last 7.5% expertise is only half as valuable as the first 7.5% by definition since it only affects parry and not dodge and parry. However, since the first half actually increases your chance to...

Forum: User Interface and AddOns 10/15/12, 9:57 PM

Replies: 2,727 Sticky: UI Help Center Views: 474,265 Posted By A1win I'm looking for an addon that can display my... I'm looking for an addon that can display my current rage (or resources in general) as a numeric value anywhere on the screen (I want it somewhere near the middle), and can dynamically change the...

Forum: Warriors 10/15/12, 8:19 AM

Replies: 850 [Cataclysm] Protection Warrior Views: 2,227,899 Posted By A1win Alright, it seems that I wasn't clear enough with... Alright, it seems that I wasn't clear enough with my posts. I took the principle of effective health for granted, and was merely trying to start a discussion on the "other things" that stamina...

Forum: Warriors 10/14/12, 6:02 PM

Replies: 850 [Cataclysm] Protection Warrior Views: 2,227,899 Posted By A1win Of course, but gems and trinkets are the only... Of course, but gems and trinkets are the only place you can get any reasonable amounts of extra stamina from at the moment. That's all I mean by "full stamina gear". I'm not saying I'm swapping off...

Forum: Warriors 10/14/12, 9:13 AM

Replies: 850 [Cataclysm] Protection Warrior Views: 2,227,899 Posted By A1win What do you mean "cannot be compared like that"?... What do you mean "cannot be compared like that"? The only comparison I've made is how much Health and how much avoidance you can get by modifying your gear. I haven't made any comparison between...

Forum: Warriors 10/13/12, 7:59 PM

Replies: 850 [Cataclysm] Protection Warrior Views: 2,227,899 Posted By A1win It's not the amount of Stamina compared to... It's not the amount of Stamina compared to secondary stats that matters. It's the amount of Health you gain compared to the avoidance you gain from the secondary stats. The stats behave in completely...

Forum: Warriors 10/12/12, 5:59 PM

Replies: 850 [Cataclysm] Protection Warrior Views: 2,227,899 Posted By A1win So, what about Stamina? At first I thought it's... So, what about Stamina? At first I thought it's useless because it "only" gives healers more time to heal you before you die. But then I started thinking a bit deeper... And here's what I've realized...

Forum: Warriors 10/10/12, 11:42 PM

Replies: 850 [Cataclysm] Protection Warrior Views: 2,227,899 Posted By A1win Based on my experience, on the discussion in the... Based on my experience, on the discussion in the MoP thread, and reading around sites, here's a rough idea for the stat weights: If there's lots of blockable damage (roughly 60%-80%):...

Forum: Warriors 08/27/09, 11:57 AM

Replies: 921 Finalizing the Prot Warrior design Views: 688,802 Posted By A1win I see a lot of the latest posts are focusing on... I see a lot of the latest posts are focusing on maximizing threat generation, even by dropping some handy survivability talents like Improved Disciplines and Improved Spell Reflection. I don't know...

Showing results 1 to 22 of 22